Discussion Board 5.1 – Mackenzie Santiago

The means of production to me is like referring to tools or resources used to produce goods and services. This to me includes factories,machines, land and technology. They control the means of production typically has power in the economic system. An example could be a company that owns a factory and the machines inside control how production happens and what and how much is being produced. Labor is a human effort, both physical and mental it goes into producing goods and services. For example a factory worker can assemble products that a teacher educating younger students or delivering drivers would transport goods.

The concept of value in the video refers to the quality of the good or service, which can often tie to the labor required to produce the product. Value is not about price but about someone who is willing to pay for the amount of labor that goes into making something. What gives value is time, effort, and skill. For instance a handcrafted table may have been more than mass produced than solo become of the labor needed. Labor and value are connected because labor is what creates value. Without human labor, raw materials would not be transformed into services and useful goods. Labor is the source of value in this economy because the more skilled intensive labor that is required to produce something the more value it has in the real world. A key distinction introduced is between labor and labor power. Labor is actual work performed while labor power is a workers ability to work like their skills, time and energy to sell to an employer. Workers don’t sell the products they may instead sell labor power for wage. An example when someone gets hired for a job and they sell their ability to work for specific hours instead of not just specific goods that are produced during that time.

Surplus value is the difference between the value between the value that workers produce through their hard labor. It represents the extra value that is generated but not returned to a workers but instead the profit is kept by the owner or employer. This concept can be important because it can explain how and why wealth can be unequal between social classes. One example can be a worker in a factory who produces $200 worth of goods in a day but only can be paid $100 in wages. The other remaining $100 would be a surplus value because of the social class it highlights the unequal relationship between workers and owners.

5.1

keilany rivera

I understand the means of production as the physical tools and resources used to produce goods and services. Labor, on the other hand, refers to the human effort involved in production, where workers apply physical and mental work to create those same goods and services. Together, labor and the means of production transform raw materials into finished products that can be sold for profit. For example, a worker in a shoe factory provides labor by operating machines, while the machines themselves represent the means of production.

Value is not the same as price. While many people confuse the two, value refers to the amount of socially necessary labor time required to produce a good. In other words, the more labor and time something takes to produce, the higher its value tends to be. For instance, handcrafted luxury bags are often more valuable than mass-produced ones because they require significantly more human labor compared to machine-made products.

Labor and value are closely connected because labor is what creates value in production. Generally, the more labor involved in making a product, the greater its value. This shows a clear relationship between the two concepts, especially when comparing handmade goods to mass-produced items.

Labor and labor power are also different concepts. Labor refers to the actual work being done, while labor power refers to a worker’s ability or capacity to work. In a capitalist system, workers sell their labor power to employers in exchange for wages, meaning they are paid for their time and ability to work rather than the full value they produce.

Surplus value is the extra value created by workers beyond what they are paid in wages. This surplus becomes profit for the capitalist. From a social perspective, this can be seen as a form of exploitation, since workers produce more value than they receive in return. An example of this can be seen in gemstone mining in parts of Africa, where miners are paid very low wages while the gems they extract generate extremely high profits for companies and owners.

1. Explain how you understand the means of production and labor. Give an example of each.

The means of production are the tools and resources needed to create a product, while labor is the effort and time workers use to make those tools to something that has value and can be sold. For instance, a coffee shop like Starbucks. In this case, the means of production would be the coffee machines, the grinders, the store building, the coffee beans, and the company’s name brand. All of these things are necessary to produce and sell the drinks. While labor is when the barista grinds the beans, steams the milk, makes the drink, takes orders, and serves the customer.

2. What is value?  What gives “value” to value, what makes something valuable? 

Value is not the same thing as price. Value is about the amount of time and effort invested in producing something. According to Marx, what makes something valuable is the labor that goes into making it. If it takes more training, skill, and time to produce something, then it has more value because it requires more labor time.

3. How are labor and value related? What’s the relationship/connection between the two?

Labor and value are connected. Labor is what starts the process, and value is the result. According to this theory, value comes from the work people put in. If no one works on something, its value stays the same. For instance, a piece of wood has some value, but if someone spends time turning it into a chair, it becomes more valuable because of the labor involved. In short, labor creates value. The more time and effort required, the higher the value.

4. How do you understand the difference between labor and labor power?

Labor is the actual activity of working, such as serving customers, building a house, or cooking food. It is the action that happens during the workday. However, labor power is different. It is the worker’s ability or capacity to work for a certain period of time. It is not the action itself, but the potential to perform that action. According to Marx, in capitalism, workers don’t sell the products they make. Instead, they sell their labor power to an employer for wages. For example, if I work an 8-hour shift, I am selling my labor power for those 8 hours. During that time, I use my energy, skills, and knowledge to do the job, which is labor. What the employer buys – pays for – is my ability to work for those hours. 

5. Surplus Value: what is it? Why is it important to know about, in our study of social classes? Think about an example of surplus value?

Surplus value is the extra value that workers create beyond what they are paid. An example of surplus value is someone working at McDonald’s earns $15 per hour. In just one hour, they might help prepare and sell much more than $15 worth of food. Even after paying for ingredients and other costs, the company still makes extra money from that worker’s labor. After a few hours, the worker has already created enough value to cover their daily wage, but they continue working the rest of their shift. The extra value created during those remaining hours goes to the company as profit. That extra portion is what Marx calls surplus value, and it helps explain why there is conflict between workers and owners.

Shanveer Singh – 5.1

  1. I understand means of production as the physical things we have aka the tools to make goods and services. On the contrary, labor as it suggests within itself is the human aspect in production where physical effort is put into making these same goods and services. To tie it all together, labor with the means of production turn raw goods into finished ones that are profitable. An example of labor is someone working at a shoe factory operating the machines, and the means of productions would be the machines themselves.
  2. The idea of value first and foremost is not the same as the price of an item. Though many think that’s the case, it is not. Value, based on the video comes from the amount of time it takes to produce something. The more labor it takes to make something, the higher the value of that item is. One example that comes to mind is that brand crafted bags are more expensive than bags that are mass produced since it takes more labor to make something by hand, rather than a machine that is churning them out. Which in the end makes the value higher.
  3. Labor and value are connected as aforementioned in the sense that labor is what makes something valuable. The classic example of this is again the difference between a mass produced good and handmade good. There is a positive correlation between the two which are labor and value, more labor means higher value.
  4. The way I see labor and labor power is that fact that labor would be the work within itself. Meanwhile labor power on the other hand is the ability of a human to work. The potential of one’s output is the labor power they can be put in as. I would put it as a worker sells the labor power they have for a wage to the capitalist.
  5. Surplus value is the extra value (profit) created by the workers, which would line the pockets of the owner. It is important to see this in social classes as it is the straight lawful way to exploit people in a capitalist society. The worker is doing more than he is being paid for which lines the pockets of the capitalist. An example of surplus value is the gem mines in Africa, poor miners are paid a wage to find gems and diamond which is worth beyond their wages in their entire lifetime.

John Fung – Discussion 5.1

1. Labor is commonly attributed to those that have to exchange their ability to work, to literally labor, where a means of production is something where laborers work to create something of value. For instance, a factory is a means of production but requires workers to provide labor in order to manufacture something to then sell.

2. According to the video, value is defined by how much labor is needed to produce under normal circumstances. If it takes a specific amount of labor to make a house, its value is determined by how much or how little labor is needed to make it from raw material to finished product.

3. Labor and value are intrinsically tied together; without labor, a product’s value is more difficult to measure if we can’t determine the cost to produce it. Even if we were to take something found in nature, labor is still needed to harvest, transport, store before exchanging for something one might need or want, which would be measured against the value of the good(s) it is being exchanged for.

4. Labor is measured by the people who can rent or sell their ability to work, thus also possessing labor power; the ability to negotiate the price of what their time and ability/skill is worth to those that need it. If Person A can produce more or faster than Person B, again under normal circumstances, then the labor of Person A is theoretically worth more since over a long period, the value produced by Person A will outpace Person B.

5. Surplus value can be look at as profit, or the excess value generated by labor after accounting for the value needed to acquire labor. If it costs a business to pay Person A $45k/yr but their work brings in $100k/yr, the surplus value would be $55k; the value of keeping Person A employed has already been returned and the excess now goes to the business, establishing the surplus value or profit.

Jonathan Kennedy- Discussion Board 5.1

  1. The means of production are all the physical and tangible components required for the creation of commodities and services. These are factories, land, machines, tools, materials, and technology, etc. The means of production exclude the human factor. For instance, in a fast-food outlet, the means of production are the grills, fryers, building, and food supplies. Production also involves the use of human resources, in both physical and mental terms, and it is he/she who converts these materials into something useful. For example, fast food workers who are cooking the food and taking orders are also providing the labor. Means of production are the resources and tools, and labor is what sets them into motion.
  2. Based on the video, value is not just about how much someone likes something. It has to do with how much socially necessary labor time it takes to produce a commodity. What gives something value is the amount of labor required to make it under normal working conditions. So something is valuable because labor was put into it. If no human labor is involved, it doesn’t have economic value in this sense. Value comes from the work that goes into producing something.
  3. The basis of a capitalist economy is the fact that labor creates value. When workers exert their labor on the means of production, they produce more valuable commodities. There can be no production without labor, and no value. Thus, in a capitalist economy, labor is the primary source of value.
  4. The difference between labor and labor power is really important. Labor is the actual work someone performs. Labor power is the worker’s ability or capacity to work. Under capitalism, workers don’t sell the products they make they sell their labor power to an employer for wages. The employer then uses that labor power to generate labor during the workday. So labor power is potential, and labor is the action.
  5. Surplus value is the additional value produced by employees which is not compensated in their wages. It is the gap in value between what an employee generates for the company compared to what he/she gets paid. For instance, a laborer may produce 300 dollars worth of goods in one day yet his/her wage is only 120 dollars. In this case, 180 dollars becomes the owner’s surplus value. It is an important concept because it demonstrates how profit is made and the reason for social class disparity. It illustrates how the wealth of the owners of the means of production is derived from the labor of employees that is not paid.

Stephanie Cesar – Discussion Board 5.1

  1. Means of production stands for how we’re able to make something. They can be physical tools, resources or even an entire place that’s dedicated solely to producing. Means of production is the starting point for how we’re able to maintain goods. An example would be a baker owning a bakery. If I were a baker, my means of production would be my kitchen equipment: mixer, oven, and fridge. Next, labor is the human exertion that’s applied to be able to make goods. Without labor, means of production wouldn’t really mean anything. The value of a good comes from the labor that was put into it, not the means of its production. It’s the interaction with the equipment to make a good. Furthering the baker example, the skills the baker utilizes to make goods would be the labor. Knowing precisely how to turn flour into a cake, the exact form and temperature to bake it in is all labor.
  2. Value is the worth/price of a good based off of the time and amount applied to produce it. All the time it takes to produce a specific item determines if it’s cheap or expensive. One vanilla cupcake is priced at how long it takes the baker to make it.
  3. Labor and value are related because one determines the other. Labor determines the value that’s assigned to a product. The amount of time/effort that’s put into creating something (labor) tallies into a final price point based on this (value). Since a vanilla cupcake takes less effort than a three tiered cake, it will be priced at a way lower point than the cake.
  4. Labor is the effort put into something, the interaction of a human and the means of production. While labor power is a worker’s capacity/ability to perform. We sell our labor power in exchange for hourly pay. The key difference between these two is that our labor power is paid at the bare minimum just so we can do it again. But our labor is valued way more than our labor power. For an example, someone will be paid $15 dollars an hour at a bakery to make cupcakes. But if the cupcakes are priced at $6.99, and the bakery sells 20 of them in 1 hour, the bakery makes $139.80 dollars while the worker is paid $15.
  5. Surplus value is a separate type of value that comes from unpaid labor produced by workers that capital owners profit off of. Workers produce way more than what they are paid for by the hour, and all of this extra money is pocketed by the employer. It highlights the imbalance between the working class and the rich. The rich profit off of all the extended labor of the workers, but the workers are skimped solely for the gain of higher class people. An example would be how the baker making $15 dollars an hour produces 20 $6.99 cupcakes that all get sold within the hour. Totaling to $139.80 for the hour. A portion of this, lets say $40 dollars would go to keeping up the means of production. Taking away $15 for the worker, and $40 dollars for the means of production, the owner is left with a grand total of $84.80 to keep.

Discussion Board 5.1 – Brittney Coard

1. Means of production and labor 

The means of production are the tools and resources needed to produce goods or services. This includes things like machines, buildings, land, or technology. For example, in a clothing store, the store space, clothing inventory, cash register, and storage area would be considered the means of production because they are needed to sell products. Labor is the work people do to create those goods or services, such as employees stocking shelves, assisting customers, and operating the register.

2. What is value? 

Based on the video, value comes from the amount of labor time put into producing something. It is not just about opinion or price, but how much socially necessary work is required to make a product. For example, a wooden table becomes valuable because of the labor involved in cutting the wood, shaping the pieces, assembling the table, and finishing it for use.

3. Relationship between labor and value 

Labor and value are connected because labor creates value. Raw materials or tools alone do not create useful products until workers use their labor. The more labor time needed to produce something, the more value it tends to have.

4. Labor vs. labor power 

Labor is the actual work that workers perform during their job. Labor power is the worker’s ability or capacity to work, which they sell to employers for wages. In other words, workers sell their labor power, and labor happens when they perform tasks on the job.

5. Surplus value 

Surplus value is the extra value workers produce beyond what they are paid in wages. It is important for understanding social class because it shows how business owners make profit from workers’ labor. For example, if a worker produces goods that sell for more than their wages and production costs, the remaining amount becomes surplus value for the owner.

Discussion 5.1

  1. The means of production are tools, materials, and spaces used to produce goods such as land, technology, factories and more. Labor is the human work that uses those tools to actually produce something. For example, in a restaurant, the kitchen equipment and building are the means of production, meanwhile the cooks and servers represent labor. Production always requires both because tools alone cannot create anything without people using them.
  2. In the video, value comes from labor. A product is valuable because of the amount of socially necessary labor required to produce it under normal conditions. This means value is not just about price or popularity, it also reflects the human effort put into the product.
  3. Labor and value are directly connected because labor is what creates value. Marx’s theory argues that new value in society comes from human work, not from machines or money alone. Workers transform materials into useful goods so that they’re able to generate value. Without labor, there would be no products, meaning no value to exchange.
  4. Labor is the actual work someone performs, while labor power is their ability to work. This distinction matters because workers are paid for their labor power, not for the full value their labor produces. The gap between the two explains how profit becomes possible in capitalism.
  5. Surplus value is the extra value workers create beyond what they are paid in wages. It is important because Marx used it to explain where profit comes from and why class inequality exists. When employers pay workers less than the value they’ve produced, the remaining value becomes profit for the owners. An example would be, if a worker is getting paid $200 for a shift but produces $600 worth of goods or services, the difference contributes to surplus value. Being able to understand surplus value helps explain how social class is formed around and who produces value plus controls it.

Discussion Board 5.1

1.Meaning of Labor and Production

The means of production are the tool or resources used to produce goods or services. It’s the items you need in order to make something, for example a pizzeria needing a pizza oven to bake pizza. Labor is the work humans do to produce these goods and services, for example the baker needing the dough to make the pizza.

2.Whats value ?

Based on the video, value comes from the labor time human put in to producing these goods or services, instead of being based on opinion its based of how time is put into the work.

  • 3.Comparison between labor and value

Labor creates the value, without the hard work from the workers , materials sourced or produced dont get used. The more labor time required, the more value it has.

4.Labor vs. labor power

Labor is the work actually performed by the workers, vs. labor power being the workers capacity to work.

5.Surplus value ?

Surplus value is basically the extra work the worker puts in beyond there wages. Usually half of the time whatever extra money the workers make, the capitalist keeps.