Discussion 13

  1. According to MLK “A just law is a man-made code that squares with the moral law or the law of God. An unjust law is a code that is out of harmony with the moral law. To put it in the terms of St. Thomas Aquinas: An unjust law is a human law that is not rooted in eternal law and natural law. Any law that uplifts human personality is just. Any law that degrades human personality is unjust.”

2. Yes, in my opinion, this is an important distinction because it shapes our society as a whole and influences how we can act accordingly.

3. One example of just law Voting Rights Act of 1965 (and its enforcement today). It protects one important democratic rights equally for all citizens. One example of Unjust law Cash bail system. It’s unjust because Harms vulnerable people while overlooking the root causes of poverty.

Discussion Board 13

According to MLK, we can tell the difference between just and unjust laws by realizing that a JUST law is “a man-made code that squares with the moral law or the law of God”. Any law that uplifts human personality is just. Also, MLK states that a unjust law is “a man-made code out of harmony with the moral law”. If we aren’t given our constitutional and god-given rights then that is unjust. When we are living in constant fear, not knowing what to expect next, then our laws are unjust and need to be changed.

This is a important distinction between just and unjust laws because any law that causes individuals to get treated unfairly in the justice system and outside of it is unjust. These laws that degrade a humans life is not moral. An unjust law does make a difference in the way someone lives their lives because it can cause the individual to not succeed in life, lowering their quality of life. For example, black people weren’t allowed to own property or even put money in the bank at one point. An individual cannot flourish if their country is actively acting against them and suppressing them.

One example of a just law put in place recently in the U.S is the decision to enforce the mandatory inclusion of LGBTQ+ themed materials in elementary classrooms. This offers more education towards the LGBTQ+ community. It also these individuals are more incorporated (by the government) as equal members of our society, making this a just law. One example of a unjust law in recent U.S history is that the Department of Justice finalized a rule that removes “disparate impact liability”. This legal concept being eliminated means that organizations that receive federal funds will no longer be held liable for discrimination offenses when their policies lead to unequal results for different racial groups. This is unjust because people’s personalities can be degraded by these organizations and they will not be penalized for it.

Discussion Board 13 – Kayana Taylor

In “Letter from Birmingham Jail,” Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. explains that the difference between just and unjust laws comes down to moral grounding and human dignity. A just law, he writes, is one that “squares with the moral law or the law of God” and uplifts human personality. An unjust law, by contrast, is one that “degrades human personality” or is inflicted on a minority group without their participation in making the law. In other words, we can tell the difference by asking: Does this law respect people’s humanity, equality, and agency? Or does it diminish and control them?

I think this distinction is extremely important. If people cannot question the morality of laws, then legality becomes the same as justice which history clearly shows is not true. Being able to recognize unjust laws affects both individuals and society because it influences how we respond to authority. Some people might choose civil disobedience, while others push for reform through political participation. These ideas absolutely shape our politics today, especially debates around rights, policing, immigration, reproductive freedom, and voting access.

Using King’s definitions, a just law in the U.S. today would be the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA). It uplifts human personality by ensuring equal access to jobs, public spaces, and transportation. It expands dignity and participation instead of restricting it.

An example of an unjust law would be voter ID laws that disproportionately impact minority and low-income communities. While they appear neutral on the surface, their impact is unequal, they make it harder for certain groups to participate in shaping the laws that govern them. Under King’s framework, this is unjust because it limits democratic agency and contributes to political inequality.

Overall, MLK’s distinction helps us think more critically about the difference between what is legal and what is right. A question that continues to shape American life and politics today.

Discussion Board 13: Natalya Rodriguez

MLK said that a fair law boosts people’s self-respect and fits with what’s morally right. An unfair law, though, puts people down or isn’t applied the same way to everyone. A law turns bad when a bigger group forces it on a smaller group that didn’t really get to help make it, or when the bigger group doesn’t even follow its own rules.

       I believe that this difference matters a lot because it changes how people view the law and if they feel they should follow it. It also shapes politics because groups and law changes start from calling out unfair laws and wanting laws that truly protect people’s rights. Today, a bad law could be rules that make being homeless a crime, because they punish people for things they can’t control and make them feel worthless. A good law would be protections against discrimination, because they stop unfair behavior and back equal worth.

Cherub A.- Discussion Board 13

  1. A Just law uplifts human integrity and dignity, an unjust law hinders or makes people inferior.

2. Yes, it guides how we treat others, shapes social behavior, and affects political decisions.

3. Unjust law: Criminalizing homelessness- it harms human dignity. Just law: The Civil Rights Act- it protects equality and dignity.

Discussion Board 13 – Divya B.

  1. MLK says a just law is a law that matches moral values and lifts people up. It respects human dignity and treats everyone fairly. An unjust law is one that goes against moral values and brings people down. It harms people, treats them unequally, or is created by a majority and forced on a minority who had no real say. A simple way to tell the difference is that just laws uplift people, while unjust laws degrade them.

  2. This difference is important because a law can be legal but still be morally wrong. Understanding this helps individuals and society decide when a law should be followed, questioned, or changed. It also affects politics, because many political debates are really about whether a law is fair or unfair.

  3. A just law today would be the Americans with Disabilities Act. It is just because it protects people with disabilities and gives them equal opportunities, which supports human dignity. An unjust law today would be cash-bail systems in many states, where people who cannot afford bail stay in jail before trial. This punishes people for being poor and treats people unequally, which fits MLK’s idea of an unjust law.

Pedro Payano/ Discussion board 13

  1. Martin Luther King Jr. wrote in his Letter from Birmingham Jail that the difference between fair and unfair laws is whether they help or hurt people.  A fair law is one that treats everyone the same, respects human dignity, and follows moral rules.  An unjust law, on the other hand, is one that lowers the worth of people, enforces inequality, or is forced on a small group of people without their permission.  King used segregation laws as an example of unfair laws because they treated Black people as less than people and took away their basic rights.  Laws that make it harder for some groups to vote are a modern example of this. They unfairly limit people’s ability to participate in democracy. Laws that protect equal rights, like those that make discrimination illegal, are fair because they promote fairness and respect.  King’s point is that we should judge laws not only by whether they are written down, but also by whether they really do justice.
  2. The distinction between just and unjust laws is significant as it influences individual conduct and societal functioning.  Martin Luther King Jr. said that a fair law raises people’s dignity and applies to everyone the same way. An unfair law, on the other hand, lowers people’s dignity and enforces inequality. This is important because if people don’t fight against unfair laws, oppression will keep going on. But if they do, change is possible. Laws that segregate people are unfair because they make Black people seem less important. Laws that stop discrimination are fair because they promote fairness. This difference also has an effect on politics. Unjust laws divide people and make them distrustful, while just laws make democracy stronger and make people believe in the system. King’s point is that we should judge laws not only by whether they are written down, but also by whether they really serve justice.
  3. We can see examples of both unfair and fair laws in the United States today, as Martin Luther King Jr. said in his Letter from Birmingham Jail.  An unfair law would be one that makes it harder for certain groups of people to vote, like strict voter ID laws that make it harder for low-income people, the elderly, or people of color to vote. This fits King’s definition of unfair laws because it enforces inequality and takes away people’s dignity by not letting everyone participate equally in democracy. The Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) is an example of a fair law. It says that schools, workplaces, and public places must make accommodations for people with disabilities. This law protects human dignity by making sure that everyone has the same chances and access. King’s framework says that unjust laws are those that keep people out or hurt them, while just laws are those that protect rights and promote fairness. This difference is still important for how we live and how our politics work today.

Discussion Board 13 Kyaw Thu Win 24602397

  1. MLK says we can tell the difference between a just and unjust law by looking at if the law is fair and respectful to human beings. A just law is something that lifts people up and treats everyone equal. An unjust law is something that hurts people, makes them feel less, or targets a minority group who didn’t even have a chance to vote or speak about that law. So basically, if a law is fair and helps human dignity, it is just. If it creates inequality, it is unjust.
  2. I think this difference is important because if people don’t know it, they might follow bad laws just because they are “legal.” Understanding this helps people see when the government is doing something unfair. It also affects politics, because when people believe a law is unjust, they protest or try to vote for change. So yes, it really makes a difference in how people live and how politics move.
  3. A just law today would be something like the Civil Rights Act, which protects people from discrimination. This follows MLK’s idea because it gives equal rights and lifts human dignity. An unjust law example could be strict voter ID laws in some states. These laws make it harder for minorities or poor people to vote, so it matches MLK’s meaning of an unjust law, because it creates unfair barriers for some groups.

Edith Veliz – Discussion Board 13.1

  1. According to Martin Luther King we can tell the difference between just and unjust laws because a just law is a law that aligns with moral principles, meanwhile unjust laws are the opposite and don’t align with morality and often are used to degrade a specific group of people. For example, in his letter “ A Letter From Birmingham Jail” it states “A just law is a man-made code that squares with the moral law or the law of God. An unjust law is a code that is out of harmony with the moral law. To put it in the terms of St. Thomas Aquinas: An unjust law is a human law that is not rooted in eternal law and natural law. Any law that uplifts human personality is just. Any law that degrades human personality is unjust.” This quote shows Martin’s way of telling the two type of laws apart and how he knows when he should or should not follow one.
  1. In my view this distinction between just and unjust laws is important because it puts into perspective how one may react the next time they see someone in their community being mistreated. I do believe this can make a difference in how either an individual or our whole society lives their life by maybe changing the way they see the world allowing them to put themselves in the shoes of others. Their politics could also be affected because this could even change the way they see their leaders. For example, in his letter “ A Letter From Birmingham Jail” Martin Luther King states “Perhaps it is easy for those who have never felt the stinging darts of segregation to say wait. But when you have seen vicious mobs lynch your mothers and fathers at will and drown your sisters and brothers at whim; when you have seen hate-filled policemen curse, kick, brutalize, and even kill your black brothers and sisters with impunity” This quote shows Martin’s approach to people who may tell people that are walking along slide him that they should just wait for a change. He is describing to them the type of unjust rules they have to live with just for being the color they are.
  1. An example of an unjust law is the discrimination between same sex marriages. In Martin’s definition of what makes a law just or unjust this would be considered unjust because it doesn’t follow moral principles and it is discriminating against a group of people simply because of their sexual orientation. An example of a more just law would be the ability to have freedom of speech unless it is a threat to someone or is violent. This would be considered just by Martin’s definition because it gives people freedom to speak their mind.

Discussion board 13


1) Just laws are human made laws are also called moral laws. It’s basically to treat people fairly. Unjust laws harm people. MLK says that the difference is based on morality and fairness. MLK believes that if a law harms a group of people then it is unjust.

2) yes the distinction is important. It is important because it helps people understand and think before just following the law without having a clear understanding of it. It is important because it minimizes discrimination and inequality. Knowing the difference between just and unjust laws effects how we live and how individuals view justice.

    3) An example of an unjust law today is for example in some states a person is not allowed to vote if they don’t have an ID. This is not fair because so some people can not afford to get an ID. According to MLK this is unjust because it is limiting the voices of citizens. An example of just laws today is The Americans with disabilities act. This act requires public places, workplaces to be accessible to people with disabilities. According to MLK this is a just law because it ensure equal treatment to individuals.