Discussion Board 5.1 – Divya Bajwa

The means of production are the tools and things people use to make products, like machines, land, or materials. For example, a bakery’s oven and ingredients are means of production. Labor means the work people do, like a baker making cakes.

Value is what makes something important or useful to people. Something has value when people need it and when work is put into making it. Labor and value are connected because the harder or longer someone works to make something, the more value it can have.

Labor power means a person’s ability to work, and labor is the actual work they do. For example, when someone is hired, they sell their labor power, and when they work, it becomes labor.

Surplus value is the extra money made from a worker’s effort that goes to the owner, not the worker. For example, if a worker makes $200 worth of goods but gets paid $100, the owner keeps the extra $100 as profit.

Discussion Board 5.1

1. The means of production and labor are two significant ideas in the video. The means of production include tools, equipment, technology, and resources required to produce goods or services. As an example, a sewing machine, a cloth, and a scissors are some of the means of production used in the production of clothes. Labor to me is the human initiative and expertise that is applied to run those tools and convert the raw materials into finished products. An example is a seamstress who uses a sewing machine and cloth to create clothes, which is a form of labor. 

2. Value is not merely the price but socially necessary labor time which is needed to produce something in normal conditions. The value of something is determined by the level of human labor time and effort put into it. The training of a doctor is socially necessary labor time more than that of a cashier, and that is the reason why society values the profession more. 

3. Labor and value are related because labor is the source of value. Raw materials alone are not of much value, but when labor is applied to them and converts them into completed goods, they gain value. Both the readings and the video emphasize that it is only labor that can add new value to capital, but not machines or materials. 

4. How I understand labor and labor power is that the real work is labor, the hours you are working on creating something. Labor power refers to your aptitude or ability to work, which you sell to a worker. The ability should be sustained by food, shelter, and rest.

 5. Surplus value is the additional value produced when workers exceed what is necessary to maintain them (salaries). It is the gap between the value that workers generate and their wages. This idea is significant as it describes the manner in which capitalists make a profit and the reason Marx considered capitalism to be exploitative. To illustrate, when you labor four hours to earn your wage, and work eight hours per day, the extra four hours of labor create surplus value to your employer and not to you.

    Discussion Board 5.1 Johnny Da Silva

    In order to make a product, the two things that are needed are labor and means of production. This means that nothing can be made or created if there isn’t labor available as well as means of production such as tools, machines, etc.

    The Labor Theory of Value says that the value added to a product depens on the amount of labor that it has been invested on creating that good. This is one theory that makes a lot of sense, but in our capitalist society, we see more of a profit and earnings to be focused on more than just the amount of work that was added to it.

    Capitalistic production are based on owning the means of production by a private party, and then the worker class can use the tools to create something, but they don’t own what they create, they only sell their labor to the owners.

    Which leads to the last question, that as working-class, we don’t own anything that we make, we’re only hired for our labor work, and everything that is created is sold by the owners for profit. The head of any company profit off the low pay for the working class and keeping the profits of the products.

    Discussion 5.1- Hemwattie Niwaz

    1. Marx on Labor and Class Conflict stated that in order to make any product you will need the means of production, and labor. Means of production- “Means of production are privately owned, rather than owned by the laborers and the products are sold in a market for profit” For example a bakery chef would need equipment such as an oven in order to bake products like cupcakes, bread, cakes, etch to sell in the marketplace for profit. Another concept is Labor. “Labor is is measured in time, hours, and minutes: the more labor time it takes to make something, the more valuable it is” In other words, labor is the physical work that is measured by time in order to create a product.

    2. What is value? According to the video on Marx on Labor Class Conflict, “A product’s value is measured by how much labor it takes to produce under normal circumstances”, meaning that the time and efforts in labor is what makes up the production’s value. The time and great amount on labor of production is what makes something valuable.

    3. According to the video, labor and value are related because labor plays a significant role by creating the value. The working class is what creates and produces value. Labor and value are connected labor is the source of value.

    4. In the video on Marx on Labor Class Conflict, I I understand that the difference between labor and labor power is that labor is regular work performed by the working class to produce products, whereas labor power are the workers who has the ability to put more physical energy, time, and skills to produce the most important commodities that increases the value, in exchange for a wage. 

     

    Discussion Board 5.1

    1. From what I understand, the means of production refers to the resources a privately owned entity obtains to produce goods and services . These resources can include machinery, land, tools and above all else, labor power. An example of means of production is a grocery store such as Trader Joes who uses it’s a building for its storefront, cash registers for transactions, delivery trucks for imported products and employees to help sell and organize the items for profit. Labor refers to the actual work done by people who are employed by this company, such as cashiers checking out the customers and stockers who unload the product to put out on the shelves for sale. The means of production provides the tools and structure, labor creates the value of the products sold for profit.

    2) Based on the video, value is represented as the worth something has within society and the economic system. Value comes from the amount of labor and resources that is invested into a product or service to make it profitable. For example, a pair of sneakers doesn’t hold value until a designer puts a specific design or logo on them, then it is passed on to be marketed by someone else who has to put in labor to network the item but before all of that, it takes someone else’s labor to even create the product through fabrics and rubber ( resources) that eventually make an item that people want to buy. Questions to consider when determining the ‘value’ of something is : ‘Is it useful?’ & ‘How much labor was put into making it?’

    3) Labor and value are related because it is labor that goes into producing a product or service which eventually turns into something people deem as valuable. For example, to reflect on my response in #2, until the fabric, rubber and/or leather is combined into making the sneaker/shoe, they hold little to no value on their own. When the person who assembles these various resources by using tools and machinery turns them into one product (the footwear), it can then be sold at whatever price the market and/or the owner of the production calls for.

    4) The difference between labor and labor power is that labor is the actual work that goes into producing a product or service, whereas labor power can only be found in people* and it correlates to the worker’s ability or potential to work. An example used in the video was the fact that many people depend on outside factors to get them through their shifts at work: transportation, food (energy), shelter, clothes etc..; Without some of these factors met outside of work, workers cannot produce labor power to get the job done.

    5) Surplus value is based on the extra value workers put into producing a product or service for the owner but does not see that returned back to them in wages. Capitalists depend on surplus value to keep on building wealth because they are only paying out a fraction of what workers produce compared to how much they’re actually making off of the product or service itself. For example, in factories across the world, there are workers putting in labor for wages as low as $3 an hour for one pair of shoes that’s being sold in America for $200. This is a clear indication of how capitalists continue to build wealth while workers remain under paid.

    Discussion Board 5.1 Chariel Mendez

    1. Two concepts presented in the video are labor and means of production. Labor refers to the time and effort that it takes to produce something. Labor is measured in time because we are exchanging our time for money. For example, you go in to work a 8 hour shift expecting to get paid for that day, you are sacrificing time out of your day in exchange for payment. Means of production are the resources needed in order to produce something. For example, a new company might need to build a facility and hire workers in order to get their business running.
    2. Value is the amount of labor it takes to produce something. The value of said product is based on how long the product took to be made, usually under normal conditions, the longer a product takes to be made, the more valuable it is. Also the rarity of the product can determine its value as well. 
    3. Labor and value are related because the longer it takes to make something (the more labor intensive that it is) then the value will be higher. Things that are harder to acquire usually hold more value than products that are easy to make. 
    4. The difference between labor and labor power to my understanding is that labor refers to the work that an individual does in order to produce something. Labor can be measured in time since an individual trades their time for payment. Labor power is the time and resources it takes to produce a certain product. This is different from labor because labor power measures the capacity at which a group of workers may work at.
    5. Surplus Value is essentially the profit that your boss is making off of you. Surplus Value refers to the extra amount of labor that you are putting in at a job. An example of this could be working mandatory overtime at a warehouse job.

    Cherub A.- Discussion post 5.1

    1. Means of production and labor, In computer science terms, the means of production are like the hardware and frameworks that make programming possible servers, compilers, and libraries. Labor is the actual coding done by the developer. For example, a programmer writing algorithms in Python (labor) relies on the IDE, compiler, and machine (means of production) to create working software.
    2. Value is like the functional output of a program. Raw code in a repository or idle hardware has little worth until it is executed to solve a problem. The usefulness of software, such as a fast algorithm or a reliable app, reflects the labor embedded in its design and execution.

    3. Labor directly creates value, much like CPU cycles create program output. Without the programmer’s effort, the tools alone cannot produce working code. The amount of socially necessary labor time put into development determines how valuable the final product is to others.

    4. Labor power is like the CPU’s processing capacity, while labor is the actual execution of instructions. Workers sell their ability to work (labor power), but what gets executed, the actual coding tasks is determined by the employer. The employer captures the results, much like a system owner controls the output of processes run on their hardware.

    5. Surplus value is the difference between what a worker is paid and what their work produces. In CS terms, a programmer may be paid for 8 hours of coding, but the software they create could generate far more revenue for the company. That extra profit, like unused CPU cycles repurposed for other tasks, becomes surplus value for the owner rather than the worker.


    Kayana Taylor

    1. The means of production are the tools, machines, land, and resources used to produce goods. For example, in a clothing factory, the sewing machines and fabric are part of the means of production. Labor is the human effort that goes into turning those resources into goods. In the factory, its the workers using their skills and energy to make the clothes.
    2. In Marxist terms, value come from human labor. What gives something “value” is not just it’s usefulness but the amount of socially necessary labor time that went into making it. For example, a handmade table might be valuable because of the hours of skilled work it took to craft it.
    3. Labor creates value. Without human effort applied to resources, they remain just raw materials. The amount of labor invested in production is what determines the value of a commodity.
    4. Labor is the actual work performed, while labor power is the worker’s ability or capacity to work. Employers don’t just buy someone’s labor for one task, they buy their labor power for a period of time like an 8 hour shift. Which can produce more value than the worker is compensated for.
    5. Surplus value is the extra value created by workers beyond what they are paid in wages. For example, if a worker is paid $100 for a day’s work but the value of what they produce in that day is $300, the $200 difference is surplus value, which the employer keeps as profit. This concept is important for studying social class because it highlights exploitation, and how profit under capitalism comes from extracting more value from labor than workers receive in return.

    Discussion Board 5.1 – Katherine Hernandez

    1.  Means of production and labor

    • Means of production are tools such as, machines, factories, land, and materials needed to make something. 

    For example: a factory building, sewing machines, and cloth are the means of production in making clothes.

    • Labor is the human effort both physical and mental that goes into making something. 

    For example: A construction worker building a house, their physical effort of laying bricks, pouring concrete, or installing windows is the labor that turns raw materials into a finished home.


    2.   Value

    • According to the video, value comes from the amount of labor time it takes to produce a product under normal conditions.
    • What gives something “value” is the human labor embedded in it. 

     3.    Labor and value relationship

    • Labor is what creates value. The more time it takes to make something, the more valuable the product is. Without labor, the raw materials are of no value.

      4.     Labor vs. labor power

    Labor is the actual work you do, like typing on a computer or building a home.

    Labor power is one’s capacity and or ability to work. Such as time, energy, and skills that you sell to your employer in exchange for pay. 


    5. Surplus Value

    Surplus value is the extra value that workers create during their jobs but don’t get paid for. In other words, it’s the difference between the value of what a worker puts in and the pay they actually earn. This idea is important when studying social classes because it shines light to what actually goes on in our world. Workers may feel like they’re being paid fairly since they get a regular wage, but in reality, their labor creates much more value than they receive back. The extra value goes to the owners, making them richer for work they didn’t have to do. Understanding surplus value helps explain why class divisions exist and why workers often struggle even though they’re the ones producing the wealth.

    Pedro Payano

    The diagrams C–M–C and M–C–M’ show two different ways of thinking about economics that are linked to different social classes. In the C–M–C cycle, which is common among small-scale producers or workers, someone sells a good they made (C) to get money (M), which they then use to buy another good they need (C). This process is based on use-value and the need to stay alive. The M–C–M’ cycle, on the other hand, is the general formula for capital. In this cycle, a capitalist starts with money (M), uses it to buy goods (C)—especially labor power—and ends up with more money (M’). M’ stands for surplus value, which is the extra value that workers create that is more than what they are paid. Reading 5.1 says that labor power is special because it can create more value than it costs. This lets capitalists get extra labor, or work done beyond what is needed to pay wages. This is how money turns into capital: not just by being traded, but also by being used. The capitalist reinvests the extra money to start the cycle again, using strategies like speeding up, downsizing, and hiring people on a contract basis to make more money. Over time, this system lets the capitalist class keep and grow its wealth, not by meeting people’s needs, but by controlling production and taking the value, that other people create.