There are several sub-schools of gender and sex theorists that give insight into different contrasting approaches which include materialist and psychoanalytical feminists as well as postmodern and poststructuralist theorists of gender. Psychoanalytical feminists are further divided into Laconian, Kristen, and freudian feminists. Poststructuralist theorist has been contesting the historical feminist discrimination between nature as well as nurture and Thomas Laqueur, a famous writer, happens to follow the former theorists.
Back in the era of ancient Greece and Rome, the theorists were mainly interested in then idea of sexual relations between same gender partners. Most feminists of that time followed Sappho who being an influencer openly express her desire for lesbian love. However, this notion on the same sex relations was not accepted by the majority. Thomas Laqueur, in his Making Sex, writes that the concept of sexuality in ancient time was different than modern times. Men and women were not perceived as two different genders, rather two versions of one same gender. Women were taken as slightly different version of men with clitoris as a genital in place of the penis. Laqueur come up with the conclusion that sex, like gender, is determined historically.
During the Renaissance period, Non-reproductive sexual acts including sodomy and bestiality were considered as capital offense. However, gender of sexual partners was not clarified by Parliament. The reason behind the non-clarification pf the sex of partners was the fact that the medical world has still not differentiated between male and female genitals.
During the 18th century, the concept of gender categories was naturalized. Advancement in medical science has led to the differentiation and categorization of genders (male and female). Women with all their anatomical and behavioral difference were considered opposite to men. Women were considered to be passive, sexually less active type while men were associated with aggressive and sexually associated nature. However, this concept of dimorphism also fought with older beliefs like gender is produced by performative activities and not natural. After the categorization of gender, there were initiated enlightenment values for gender equality and women’s rights. Feminists of the time argued for liberty of women and giving them equal rights to them as men. Women were not even able to enjoy basic right owing to the conflicts of race, class, and politics. Another major concept that was put forward in the 18th century was the association of masturbation with many contagious diseases. Along with prohibition from masturbation, disciplining of private parts was among the strict instructions.
During the 19th century, the concept of natural gender types was widely accepted and followed by normal procreative sexuality. However, the social society in the 19th century was divided into an upper class and middle-class cultures. The upper-class culture showed equality between men and women regarding both work and home while middle-class culture was classified onto two separate spheres:
Public sphere: This was associated with male partners and men were publicly more active. Men were considered to work outside and bring money to the house. Men were supposed to face all the struggles of industrial, political, or business nature.
Private sphere: This sphere belongs to women and it consisted of house-chores, nurture, and child-rearing jobs.
In this two phased culture, men had the privilege to enjoy both public and private spheres where they could just wing around between home and outside while women were only restricted to private space. This double sphere system were not good in bringing a good image of women to society. Women were divided into two types depending on the space were they existed such as domestic angelic and demonic whores.
The 19th century was about to bring revolution in the lives of women when Divorce Court was created which allowed women to give divorce to their spouses. Besides, sodomy was also removed from the list of capital offenses leading to the de-intensification in the regulation of sexuality in women. However, the major drawback of de-intensification in the regulation of sexuality was that prostitution was adopted as a profession of women at a big level owing to the increased population of women. The parliament had to put a stop to increasing population and CD Act was implemented. A large number of women suspected as prostitutes were arrested. However, this CD Act was suspended in 1883 due to long protest by groups of the working class and a new Act Criminal Law Amendment Act which also clearly prohibited men from any indecent act with any other man. Oscar Wilde who was allegedly reported to have sexual relations with a man had raised his voice vigorously against these kind of Acts. Along with sexuality regulation, another worth mentioning even took place in the 19th century was creating The New Women concept which was supposed to be completely denying the feminine qualities described before. The New Women wanted equal rights and place in society with men and was public, active, and aggressive as men. A completed switch between the gender was seen leading to change in concepts of home, race, and even politics. The new women who were before labeled as feminists had changed the notion every soon. Women become part of society acquiring different roles as feminists, socialists, or as child-rearing partners in the house. The male domination in the society though had not finished yet. It was forced by a lot of competition by women. This new women which emerged from 19th century and is ruling the present era has proven as a threat to male-oriented society in almost all fields of life including politics, imperialism, or economy. The 19th century has unveiled the stereotypes and created a society of natural sexuality and gender equality creating a balance between proper desires and proper roles of both genders. Feminists have still got to run a long battle to achieve the rights they are demanding.
The theories of gender and sexuality have been very distinct from each other from ancient times. Some theorists consider gender to be nurture and sex to be natural are the one who believe in insignificant subject values including race. Some of the theorists who believe in ideology and language to be the main determining factors of everything are followers of postmodernists and poststructuralist approaches. Regardless of the position, all the critics suggest us to be critically conscious of the performative natural identity.