https://docs.google.com/presentation/d/1uSVrRJorJR2xJ2Y46J_SFzMPbuSMchRUh5FcveYhFns/edit?usp=sharing
Phi’s article highlighted the much heated topic of police brutality. Police brutality has been a consistent issue within POC. Phi’s article talks about the attitudes of Asian Americans towards police brutality. He describes the anxious feelings many POC have when encountered with police officers and details the lengths they take to stay in good graces with the police. Bio Phi explains that as long as the aggression is not directed towards the asian community, many asians stand indifferent or side leaning towards law enforcement. Phi points out that although Asian Americans are often victims of police brutality, a vast majority of them still strongly support law enforcement and are pro police activists. For me, I think Phi’s objective is to reach asian communities and lead asian readers to realize the hypocrisy among them. To be able to help them out of the “pick me” attitudes and step back to see that the asian community is also terrorized by the corrupt law enforcement and broken justice system. I find that this article encourages asian communities to align and support fellow POC and recognize that the BLM movement moves in alliance with all POC against a corrupt white glorifying system.
Zen brings up a relative topic of how Asian Americans tend to take a conservative stance regarding modern social and racial issues. She details on how multiple black perpetrated anti-asian attacks push asians to align with law enforcement. Zen also highlights the topic of affirmative action, how it affects the asian community and how it has pushed asians towards a conservative view due to the policy’s negative impact. I believe that Zen’s purpose was to challenge conservative asian views and encourage them to support minority communities and align with the BLM movement.
The main objective of the piece was to reach out to Asian readers and educate them on the struggles of being black as well as the harsh, unfair treatment that the black community faces in hopes of encouraging unity through the realization of common ground. I particularly liked how the author empathized with Asian struggle and did not dismiss it. I think that a lot of Asians do identify with white more than other POC because their history and cultural background. I think the glorification of being white stems from centuries of exploitation and lack of education which won’t go away anytime soon (as much as I want it to). Hopefully, more asians do come to a realization that racial issues affect them as much as it affects other POC and finally come together and unite to fight for a system that protects all.
Framework:
“Racism that Bridges” by Kim Tran described the many Asian immigrants who migrated to America in search of new life, opportunity, and the pursuit of happiness. These Asian immigrants were ostracized and marginalized by the white American society. Asian immigrants were physically and verbally degraded and alienated by American society. Asian immigrant groups were discriminated against heavily and would be singled out by their skin and distinctive eyes. I gravitated to this framework because as an Asian immigrant, I can relate to the struggle.
Stories
For Stories, I felt most intrigued of “Tired” by Alice Tsui. She details on how the pandemic intensified negative feelings towards Asians. Asians are severely targeted and seen as walking diseases due to the Coronavirus. Tsui talks about how she grows tiresome of the polite indifference shown to her constantly. She explains how tired she is of defending herself against the unfair discrimination she is forced to experience. This excerpt stood out to me because I heavily related to it. I experienced this treatment as well when the pandemic started. I had people tell me I didn’t know how to speak English, as well as experienced being verbally attacked and I’ve seen people look at me in distaste and disgust.
Comic
The comic “Protect Yourself, Family & Friends From Getting Sick” by Malakais Ghairib was a fun, lighthearted collaboration of drawings and explanations of the different safety precautions taken for COVID-19. I think that this comic was easy to read and understand. I also feel like it was very informative and educational. In today’s climate it is important to spread awareness in a positive way.
After reading the articles, it was very interesting to see how much false hope Asian immigrants had relative to migrating to America. All of the articles talked about their horrible experiences with immigration and the overall general American Government. Especially now in the climate we are in Trump has made is very difficult to legally migrate to the US. The articles highlighted all the struggles and brutal conditions many of these Asian refugees faced every day. ICE has played a huge factor in immigration and are still known for their brutal conditions and insensitivity. Refugees were so poorly treated that some were driven to commit suicide. America’s immigration and Refugee laws should be reformed. There should not have been this much tragedy in a country as progressive and ever evolving as America. People in power need to start fighting for people who have no voice in the economic life standards that people are enduring.
“Model Minority” was created in the 1960’s. It was used to stereotype and categorize Asian Americans as more intelligent and more likely to succeed compared to other minority groups. At this time, the U.S. preferred immigrants who were proficient in fields of science, technology, engineering and mathematics in order to improve the country and is general economy. The model minority ideal was used to identify “elite” immigrants while also undermining other minority groups like Hispanics and the Black community who were stereotyped as criminals and thugs. This trope furthered anti black rhetoric. It is evident that both opposite sides of the stereotype has dealt with different discriminations, it is without a doubt that this system is unjust, unfair and created to ultimately exploit people of color and benefit the white government per usual.
Affirmative Action moves tp create an equal opportunity platform fro minorities who are in pursuit of higher education. However, although affirmative action hold a great ideology, it has been poorly executed. Asians are commonly categorized as proficient in STEM fields. This expectation creates pressure to fit into what society feels you should be as an Asian American. This in return shuns people who fail to fit into the role that society has assigned. The rebirth of the model minority trope served politically fueled agendas that aimed to protect and serve the white system.
After reading and watching these pieces it was obvious that the criteria for citizenship was created by a biased white system that was built to solely benefit European white men and women. “White” being the standard and even ideal citizen. Personally, this information did not come as surprising but only solidified y thoughts on immigration and citizenship. The Loyalty questionnaire stands as a great example of the bias within the government in terms of citizenship.
Citizenship today is still as difficult and lengthy as ever. Especially under Trump’s administration, many good people fear for their livelihoods. In my opinion, there has to be a bias within the immigration system. Citizenship should be granted and rewarded to true, hard working people regardless of race and origin.
A.) Chinese prostitution attracted particular public attention which later on became a leading argument against asian immigration within the United States. During the late 1870’s depression an increase of anti Chinese sentiments prevailed due to the lack of job opportunities. The media ultimately blamed the Chinese for taking jobs and undercutting the white man’s ability to earn. They also spread misinformation about Asian sex workers which later becomes the basis for implementing laws that banned the immigration of many Asian women. According to Dr. Charles C.O’Donnell, A renowned doctor, “There are cases of syphilis among the whites that originated from these Chinese prostitutes that are incurable”. The majority reached a strong consensus Asian prostitutes represented a prevalent threat to the lives of the everyday white family. Aside from being blamed for the spread of sicknesses, Chinese women were also blamed for encouraging immorality among white young boys and men. Which translates to a negative drift between families and their religious faith. At this time, the AMA or American Medical Association forwarded studies about Chinese prostitutes and whether they are poisoning the nation. As stated in the excerpt of Luibheid, “The germ theory of disease provided an explanation of the manner in which an obviously inferior group might best a superior one, contrary to the natural law of social Darwinists”. The page law mandated the exclusion of Asian women coming to the United States to work as prostitutes believed to be a serious threat to white values, lives and futures.
B.) Carved in Silence showcased the trials Asian immigrants faced when they arrived in Angel Island. After faced with the Exclusion law, many men and women found different ways to be part of the exception. Some even purchased fake papers despite the expense and the risk of being caught. Angel Island was far from heavenly for these unsuspecting migrants. When settled, they were stripped away from their families and their partners for days, experienced poor living conditions and forced to cooperate with aggressive interviews and intrusive medical checkups. This would go on for weeks and even months before they can legally leave the island. To express and relieve suffering and frustrations, they turned to the written language. Immigrants within the heavily guarded compounds of Angel Island would carve countless poems without names. Later, when these poor conditions continued within the facilities, detainees founded the Angel Island Liberty Association in protest against the horrible treatment and the awful living arrangements that they faced everyday.
C.) The treatment Asian Americans face today due to COVID-19 and the insensitivity of Pres. Donald Trump is very similar to what Chinese sex workers faced during the 1870’s. The spread of misinformation and ignorance is far more contagious and unfortunate. It creates fear within people which potentially transforms into hate and mistreatment towards different persons on the basis of their race and phenotype. The treatment of immigrants in Angel Island is very similar to hoe ICE treats their detainees at the border. The only difference might be that ICE is far more vicious and merciless. It’s heartbreaking to see people being mistreated and separated from their families. Mothers and Fathers stripped from their children, women being unknowingly castrated against their will, countless cases of sexual assault and the many missing children that are unaccounted for within their facilities. It is a tragedy that these activities are facilitated by our very own government.
Hi everyone! Firstly, I hope everyone is doing well both mentally and physically. So far, this class for me has answered so many questions I didn’t even know I had. Professor Munshi has made this class both enlightening and smooth sailing. Which personally, I am in favor for. The workload is not overwhelming but it is effective in drawing out questions that this class never fails to answer. The only thing I would really change is the class interaction although I am aware that some people are introverted and shy, I’d love to get to know my cohorts better. Also, I think placing announcements and grades on Blackboard would serve the students well in terms of seeing grade progression. Overall, this class is amazing, fun, light hearted and surprisingly quite educational. I like how we dig into more than just solid history but into human ideology and social constructions over time as well. As an Asian immigrant from the Philippines, it has been an awakening experience to learn all these things I had no idea off. It gives me different perspectives of the Social communities we are a part of and allows me to gain insight on my historic identity.
A song I think would work well for this class would be Tokyo Drift by Teriyaki Boyz. The song is upbeat, iconic and energetic. Or songs by either Don Toliver or Snoh Alegra. 🙂
Race is a power of illusion created by europeans to differentiate themselves as superior. This was an economically beneficial move on their part to categorize other races and create a social construct that is race. Race has become a huge defining aspect in humanity over the years. In a written piece by Dhingra and Rodriguez, they mentioned, “Race is such a significant way of organizing and categorizing people in American society that we are often confounded when we encounter a person whose race we cannot immediately make sense of”. Which made me realize just how much race affects people daily in micro transactions. The ideology of “race” is acknowledged all the way back to colonial times to create an easier way to distinguish the colonized from the colonizers thus creating this veil of superiority. Years later, many studies were made creating a scientific reasoning towards other races deeming “white” as supreme all the while justifying the enslavement of black men and women. Of course now, modern research shows that these studies are false but at that times this misinformation was strongly believed in which only fed into the socially constructed verdict that races other than white were inferior. From the reading, “Asian America: Sociological Interdisciplinary Perspectives”, It explains to its readers how racial classifications alter through time which overall showcases the general idea that race is not just a political construct but a social and economic one as well that has nothing to do with human anatomy nor science. It is institutionalized to actively separate and differentiate different people based on European standards and it is clear that their goal was to create and instill the idea that they are the dominant, superior race.
Reading and watching multiple pieces focused on race and its roots has been a huge realization for me. In the Philippines and I’m sure many other countries, people glorify the white man. The Philippines adores light skin and straight hair while also encouraging their daughters to marry men specifically white to uplift their image. It is a sad fact that this happens in many parts of the world. Till today we still fight for representation within the media and challenge western beauty standards.
A common reason why people choose to migrate to the United States is opportunity. People come to the United States in search for a better life for themselves and their families. Education and the general standards of living in the United States are far more attainable than other countries. When my family migrated to the United States, my parents often talked about all the grand opportunities that will greet me when we land and all the hopes of attaining the “American Dream”. Compared to the Philippines, the U.S. has free schools and different socialist programs that help support low income families. The food is cheaper, the air cleaner and money if you work hard enough will fall right onto your lap. The idea of the United States in the perspective of people living in a developing country like the Philippines is a gold land filled with money and happiness for everyone.
Yang’s theory of the Push and pull factor in my opinion is more true than not. In most cases, families need to weigh both push and pull factors before deciding to leave their country and start anew in a foreign land with foreign people. Some other pull factors would be the LGBTQ culture in America. It is a right that not many people outside the U.S. get to experience. Another factor could be religion. China for example treat their muslim citizens with little regard for their betterment and no respect for their beliefs.