POL 100 Sec A050
Discussion Board 6.2
- What concept that we have already discussed does “faction” remind you of?
I am reminded of Louis Althusser’s concepts of ideology. He talks about two apparatuses: The Repressive State Apparatus (RSAs) and the Ideological State Apparatus (ISAs). The RSA is about the state’s repressive apparatus, the army, police, prisons and the courts. The ISA comprises several agencies viz., covering discipline and obedience; the Church, and schools. When reading and thinking about the majority and minority factions I had a flashback to the previous discussions.
- According to Federalist #10 what is the source of wealth (private property)? What factor explains why some people get to possess wealth by owning private property, and others don’t and remain poor)?
James Madison, the Father of the Constitution, believed that the diversity in the faculties of man point to a superiority of the educated, who belong to the minority faction. This diversity allowed for the educated, wealthy, land owning, and upper class citizens the right to re-inforce their private property portfolio and on the other hand for the poor and working class and those without advanced faculties obstacles; which are near impossible to overcome. James Madison thought that it was incumbent on the government to protect these highfalutin upper class citizens, with advanced faculties, from the majority. He preached that the government is there to see that those who represent the minority, having acquired private property are not hampered by the majority. He had firm ideas about America being a Republic and not a democracy. A thriving society with people from different backgrounds and from different social classes would fare better and would be dismissive of the minority faction lording it over them.
- Do you agree with this explanation of wealth and poverty?
I do not agree with James Madison’s explanation about wealth and poverty. His treatise, penned as the Federalist Paper #10, is apropos to his republicanism where the minority faction vote for the laws and acts as an affront to a democracy and where the direct participation of the citizenry is the order of the day. A democracy is where all the citizens can vote directly on laws rather than by the elected representatives in Congress. A place where the rich and the poor, male and female, black and white have equal rights. In the period between the American Revolution to the Constitutional Convention only property owners, white males had the right to vote. Those who were disenfranchised were the poor whites (who were not owners of property), blacks, Native Indians, women and indentured servants.
- What is the core mission (“first object”) of the US government? Does this surprise you, does it sound different from what our society today seems to suggest the core mission of the government is? Explain.
Madison saw the first object of government was to make sure that those who have the faculties to get rich should not have obstacles thrown their way by the poor, working class people. In today’s society the core mission of the government is to serve the needs of all the people by providing protection for maintaining law and order by providing economic relief, and protecting the citizens from internal and external threats. During the COVID19 pandemic the government tried to ensure our safety from the dreaded disease, by providing free testing, and free Personal Protective Equipment (PPE) i.e. face masks and by offering free vaccines. As a matter of fact I was able to take an Uber free of charge to and from a testing location. Where the government fell down was by not historically protecting the vulnerable, especially those poor black and brown people with pre-existing conditions.
- Given the discussion in questions 1-4, are you surprised that Federalist #10 is not in favor of democracy, and supports a Republican (representative) form of government? Why would the author dislike a (pure) democratic form of government?
James Madison and other framers of the US Constitution disliked a pure form of democracy so I am not surprised that in Federalist Papers #10 he supports a Republican form of government. A democracy was inimical to his upper-class interests and those of the minority faction. His class was a wealthy, slave owning, landowning and educated upper class and with all the perks that came with their status in society. He and the other framers wanted at all costs to ensure that the minority faction controlled a Republican form of government. He was afraid of the majority faction and what their role could have been in a pure democracy.
