Chelsea Ferreiras- Discussion Board 6.2

1.The word Faction reminds me of social classes or groups of people with the same interests. A faction is a group that wants things that benefit them. For example, rich property owners could be one faction and poor farmers or workers could be another. Each group wants the government to support their interests.

    2. According to Madison, wealth comes from the different abilities and talents people have. He explains that people have different skills and opportunities. Because of this, some people end up owning property and becoming rich, while others do not and stay poor.

    3. I partly agree with this idea because people do have different skills and chances in life. But I also think wealth and poverty depend on other things too, like family background, education, and opportunities. So ability is not the only reason some people are rich and others are poor.

    4. In the reading, Madison says the main job of the government is to protect property. This means protecting people’s right to own things like land, money, or businesses.This is a little surprising because today many people think the government’s main job is to help everyone and protect people’s rights. But in this reading it shows that protecting property was very important to the founders.

    5. I’m not really surprised after reading it. Madison thought that if there was too much democracy, the majority could make decisions that hurt other groups, especially wealthy property owners. Because of this, he supported a republic, where people elect representatives to make decisions instead of everyone voting directly. He believed this would help control factions and stop one group from getting too much power.

    Chelsea Ferreiras-Discussion Board 6.1

    1.Based on the readings the Constitution was mostly written by wealthy people like landowners, merchants, creditors, and slaveholders. These people had property and money so they had more influence in politics and were able to shape the government. Many of them wanted a stronger government that would protect their property and financial interests. The people who were mostly excluded were poor farmers, workers, women, enslaved people,servants, and men without property. These groups didn’t really have political power at the time and were not represented when the Constitution was written. Because of that, the Constitution mainly reflected the interests of the wealthy class instead of the lower classes.

    2.I think the social class structure was very different from today. In early U.S. society, political rights were strongly connected to property. Many people couldn’t vote unless they owned land. Women, enslaved people, and many poor men were completely excluded from politics. Today things are more democratic because most adults can vote no matter how much money they have. But even today, people with more money still seem to have more influence in politics, so social class can still matter.

    3. The people who wrote the Constitution were afraid that too much democracy would give too much power to the poor majority. Many wealthy leaders worried that ordinary people might pass laws that would hurt their wealth or property.

    Chelsea Ferreiras- Discussion Board 5.3

    1. One statistic that stood out to me the most is that the top 1% of Americans own about 40 to 50% of all the wealth in the country which is more than the bottom 90% combined. This really surprised me because it shows how unfair wealth is in the United States. This shows a very small group of people has almost half of all the money, land, and businesses, while most people have very little. The reading also says many families have little or no wealth after paying debts which makes the gap even bigger. This shows that the U.S. is not mostly middle class like people often think but most wealth is held by people at the top .

    2. Living in a society with a big gap between the rich and the poor affects people in many ways. When a small group has most of the money, they also have more power and chances, while most people have a harder time. For example rich people can pay for better schools, healthcare, and housing, and they have connections that help them succeed as well. At the same time, many regular people live paycheck to paycheck or have even have debt. We see this in everyday life. Some neighborhoods have nice homes, good schools, and many resources, while other neighborhoods have poor housing, weak schools, and fewer job opportunities. This shows how the gap between the rich and the poor affects people’s chances in life. So yes, we can clearly see this in U.S. society today because money strongly affects how people live and the opportunities that they have .

    Chelsea Ferreiras- Discussion Board 5.2

    The diagram M-C-M shows how capitalists keep and increase their money. It starts with M (money) that the capitalist already has. They use that money to buy C (commodities), which are the things that are needed to make products, like machines, materials, and the workers labor. Workers use these things to make goods that can be sold. When the goods are sold, the capitalist ends up with M (more money than they started with). The capitalist makes more money because of surplus value. Workers are paid just enough to cover basic things like food and housing. But during the day, workers create more value than what they are paid. Capitalists keep doing this over and over , they use money to make products and then sell them for more money. They also try to make more profit by making workers work longer or faster without paying them more. This is how capitalists keep getting richer .

    Chelsea Ferreiras Discussion Board 4.1

    1. Readings 4.1 and 4.2 both connect social class to money. Reading 4.1 explains that people in the U.S. usually think of class based on income, jobs, and education. Reading 4.2 also shows social class using income, but it does it by showing how New York City neighborhoods have different income levels along the subway line. Both readings show that some people have more money and opportunities than others. The difference is that Reading 4.1 focuses on how people see their own class, while Reading 4.2 shows real class differences in where people live. Both readings link class to money, but one is about people’s views and the other is about neighborhoods.

    2. I chose the 2 train because it runs near my neighborhood. Based on the subway income map, the social class that mostly lives in my area would be working class to lower middle class. This connects to Reading 4.1 because it says social class is often based on income, jobs, and education, and most people in my neighborhood have regular jobs and average incomes. I am not surprised by this because my neighborhood has mostly working families and not so many people with money. I think this is an accurate representation of the people living here since most households have similar income levels and lifestyles.

    3. Based on Reading 4.2, there is a clear pattern of social class in New York City. Richer neighborhoods are mostly in Manhattan, while more working class and lower income areas are in parts of the Bronx, Brooklyn, and Queens. The map also shows that income can change a lot in just a few subway stops. This shows that social class in NYC is strongly connected to where people live.

    Chelsea Ferreiras- Discussion Board 4.2

    1. In the reading 4.3 explains that the main difference between owners and employees is how they make their money. Owners are people who make most of their income from things they own, like businesses, stocks, or property, so they can live off profits and investments. While employees have to work for wages or a salary to make a living because they do not own big businesses or property. For example , a business owner or big investor is an owner because they earn money from what they own , while a factory worker or office worker is an employee because they depend on their job and paycheck to survive.

      2. In the reading , Adam Smith’s quote means that work done by people is what really gives things their value. He is saying that something is worth what it is because of the labor used to make it , not just because of money or materials.  Like wood would becomes something valuable like paper or furniture after workers cut the trees, shape the wood, and sell the finished product. It shows that without workers and their effort , goods and services would not be created and money by itself cannot make things.

      3. My thoughts about the main arguments of reading 4.4 are that class is not just an identity like race or gender. I agree with this argument because class clearly shapes people’s everyday lives, like how much they earn, how secure their job is, and what chances they have in life. The reading also shows that problems like racism and sexism often affect people with less money and power the most. So I understand why the author says class is more than an identity , it is a system that affects how society works.

      4. I understand the argument in reading 4.4 that “class structures are built around a close form of dependency” means that workers and employers need each other in a very direct way. Workers need employers for jobs and money to live, and employers need workers to do the work that makes money. This creates a close connection between them but they do not have the same power because employers own the business and make the rules. So the “close form of dependency” means that different classes are connected through work. For example, a factory worker depends on the company owner for a paycheck to pay bills and survive. At the same time, the owner depends on the worker to make the products so the company can sell. This shows how workers and owners are closely dependent on each other in the class system.