- Describe the primary differences in the role of citizens in government, among the federal, confederation, and unitary systems.
In a unitary system of government, the central government holds power opposed to the citizens. The unitary system still has both local and regional methods of government, but they are both under the authority of the stronger central government. This government gives directions to the lower forms of government, but never allows them to work independently. One example of a country that used the unitary system is the United Kingdom. The central government was the most powerful and granted and removed power from local governments whenever they pleased. However, this country is beginning to become decentralized leading to the development of smaller countries like Scotland, Wales, and Northern Ireland.
In a federal system of government citizens play a prominent role where they vote for representatives that the people want, and each representative has a particular function. There are two levels of government in a federal system and the first is the national government, which oversees managing issues that concern the entire country. Examples of this would be foreign terrorist threats, as well as boosting economic wealth. The second is the state government where they focus on the concerns of their state including the welfare of their people such as health care and public safety. In the United States all national affairs are conducted by the federal government. The federal government consists of both the president and Congress for which the citizens are responsible for electing. All issues regarding the state government are delt with by their respective states, that are each run by an elected governor and legislature. Although there is a difference between what the state and local government focus on, voters on each level are in control of choosing a leader.
Citizens in a confederation held little to no power because that authority belonged to the states. The states of a confederation maintain all the control of an independent nation, such as the right form a military, print currency, or construct a treaty with other powerful nations. The United States started with a confederate state because they wanted to make sure the average citizen did not have the power to make political change. Giving them this power would also be a danger to the wealthy capitalist and landowning citizens of this new country. However, this central government was much too weak to support this growing country, so a new system needed to be formed. The states refused to give up their power and the national government did not have the wherewithal to confront complications such as war debt, handling arguments amongst other states, solving issues regarding trade, or dealing with civil unrest across the country. This is when the founding fathers began to shift to a federal system while writing the constitution which gave the citizens a bit more of a prominent position.
- Briefly explain how you understand the system of division of power.
In a contemporary form of democracy, the government divides power into two distinct ways. Some countries, including the United States use a combination of both systems of government. The first way is far more popular and uses the collective power between the three branches of government, the legislative that makes laws and consists of Congress, the House of Representatives, and the Senate, the Executive that carries out the laws and includes the president, vice president, and Cabinet, and the Judicial branch that assesses the laws and is comprised of the Supreme Court as well as other courts. The second less common governmental power is federalism which distributes the power between the national and subnational levels of government. In the United States while referring to the national government you used the term “federal” and describe the subnational level as the “state government.”
- How does the federal government shape the actions of state and local governments? Write your answer based on doing a bit of research on how the federal government has influenced the actions of NY state and local governments, during the COVID-19 pandemic.
The federal government can influence each state through the process of distributing grants, incentives, and sending periodic aid. State and local governments are generally pleased to receive federal support, especially during a sever crisis. For example, at the beginning of the COVID-19 pandemic the federal government issued three stimulus checks for people who were eligible to provide economic relief for the people in each state. They were all approved by the House of Representatives, the Senate, and the president of the United States. The federal government additionally sent four massive medical stations with 1,000 beds to assist with the bed shortage in hospitals in New York City when the pandemic was at large. The federal government was also responsible for sending the USNS Comfort, a large hospital ship, to New York City to help relieve the crowding of local hospitals. Another thing the federal government implemented during the pandemic is that they dispatched the United States Army to convert the New York City’s Javits Center into a hospital which held almost 3,000 beds. Later a strong travel advisory was asked to be enforced by the governor of New York to prevent the spread of the virus through our airports and any other form of public transportation. Nobody was allowed to enter or leave the state for several months, and when the travel advisory was lifted those who traveled had to quarantine for a total of 14 days (about 2 weeks). Finally, in beginning of 2021, the federal government oversaw sending out COVID-19 vaccines across New York State. This was a grueling process as many New Yorkers scrambled to book appointments before the supply ran out. Some who booked appointments had to reschedule while they were waiting for their vaccine. It is speculated that former president Trump had a grudge on former Governor Cuomo, and because of that withheld the vaccines from New Yorkers.
New York has received almost $90 billion in federal unemployment benefits for workers who struggled as a result of the pandemic, as well as $165 billion in the CARES Act funding implemented by former president Trump. The American Rescue Plan has also sent an extra $84 billion to the state of New York. This money has helped those who are jobless and has aided those whose businesses have struggled due to the economic hardships caused by statewide business shutdowns. This federal aid also helped decrease poverty by nearly 1/4th in the beginning of 2021.