Kailynn Cambi – Discussion Board 3.1

  1. to me ideology is a shared perspective of beliefs, values, and ideas that can shape how a group of people see the world or decide what is wrong and right. It will shape the minds into seeing how they understand and process things through their perspective especially in society. And sometimes this can even happen without us even realizing it in our everyday lives. An example can be The American Dream. The belief is that anyone can achieve financial success and happiness if they just work hard enough. If you see someone financially stable you would say it is because they work hard and have talent or skills in their field. But if someone was financially struggling you would think it is the opposite for them. That they are not driven or working as hard enough or else they would be living this happy stable life. But to have a deeper understanding in Ideology is to see that they are already in our schools, media, religions, etc.. Ideologies are constantly competing against each other. We have the main ideology that keeps everything together, but then also have new ideas that also rise up to challenge it when people don’t think systems are fair. In the end ideology is the system that “holds everything together” but then also allows other to use it as a tool when trying to change it.

2.  The main reason diving the Liberals and bConservatives is how they see the government. Liberals believe the government should be more involved to solve social problems, protect the government, and make sure that everyone is treated equally. Conservatives on the other Hand want something very different. They want the government to mind their business and stay out of private business and daily lives so that people can rely on their personal responsibilities. Healthcare is such a great example because it shows how liberals think it should be provided to everyone equally while conservatives think it should be handled privately.

3. Althusser argue that ideology isn’t a collection of bad ideas but an imaginary story we tell ourselves to fit into our world perspective. Because the complex reality and society rules can be too harsh so we use this “story” to make ourselves feel independent and practice it through ordinary habits taught to us by almost anything growing up.

Annette O’Brien- DB 3.1

1: In my own opinion, Ideology is how you identify yourself, based around your own beliefs and personal circumstance. Politically, it’s a way how you’re able to articulate and express your own viewpoint, by subscribing to a personal set of ideas and values, that you also happen to believe in. While it isn’t the most accurate reflection of who one is inside, it’s a mechanism people use to display the parts of themselves that they may be most proud of. It’s the collective culmination of who you professional yourself to be.

2: For me, I identify and separate Conservatism and Liberalism using three major metrics: position regarding the New Deal, belief on government financial intervention, and stances on defense. From what I’ve learned, conservatives are concerned about maintaining freedom from government. This is articulated through their belief in a free economy, and lessened taxes. Whereas liberals believe in heavy taxes upon the rich, and government allocation of finances. Liberals also don’t concern themselves with issues of defense, as much as conservatives do. Leading them to usually be anti-gun, and more for the government to allocate funds outside of issues like national defense. Which the conservatives disagree with, and believe that that is the one major area the government should be concerning themselves. Liberals also originated their beliefs from the New Deal, whereas, conservatives believed the government was taking too much on their shoulders, during that time.

3: From my understanding, Althusser diagnosed human submission to ideologies that don’t support them, via two different apparatus’, used to make people more lenient to the idea. The first, was a utilization of fear, via the Repressive State Apparatus. Which used tools like prison, police force, and courts. As a way to punish deviation, and promote the idea of following a certain line of behavior. If you look at Nazi Germany, for example (because it’s one of the examples provided), this would take the form something like being arrested, for not following the fascist identity. The second apparatus, is the Ideological State Apparatus. Which instead of utilizing fear, it utilizes people’s desire to actually belong. Using social order as a tool, through things like school, politics, and mass media. Returning back to the fascist example, this apparatus could take the form of fascism becoming an identity of the people. And that, if you were to oppose it, then you had no place among your people.

RHANDOL DE LA CRUZ – Ideologies

To me, ideology is a set of beliefs and ideas that shapes how we see society as well as what we believe is right and how people think everything should work. It affects what we consider good , wrong fair or unfair. Sometimes we do not even notice our ideology because the beliefs we grew up with can feel like common sense.

For example, many people believe that if you work hard, you will automatically become successful. That idea can influence how someone thinks about people who are rich or poor and this is because it will make people think that someone who is poor didnt work hard enough when in reality thats not true their circumstances may not have allowed them to put themselves in a better place, things like family, background, and opportunities as well as what jobs are even open at the moment create a gap between thriving and surviving. Ideology is important because it helps shape our opinions about politics and everyday issues. It can also explain why two people can look at the sample problem but have completely different views on it because of how they was raised or what they were told as a child.

I think one of the biggest differences between conservative and liberal ideology is how they view government, individual responsibility , equality , and change. Conservatives generally support limited government, free markets, and traditional values. Liberals generally side with government involvement when it can help make equality, protect rights and solve social problems that affect minorities and people with different social statuses. One example I could give is college cost matter more to liberals when it comes to the government, they will give more support if the government is providing more financial assistance to students. A conservative might believe individuals should be more responsible for paying for their own education and that government spending should be limited. This shows how the two ideologies can have different views and opinions.

I understand Althussers idea of ideology as the belief that society teaches us certain views on things and behaviors through things like school, religion, your family, the government you are under in for example America and Russia , and social media. Over time these views can feel normal to a person when society helps teach this, When a student goes to school he is expected to follow a number amount of rules, like following a schedule to not be late, listen to authority people telling you what to do, raise your hand when you want something etc. Althusser might say school is teaching people how they are expected to behave in society.

Justin LeGendre – Discussion Board 3.1

  1. I understand ideology as something that acts as a guiding factor in how you view the real world. It is a set of beliefs and values that help shape how you think socially and politically, including what you believe is right or wrong and how society should work. Ideology can be shaped by beliefs passed down to you, your environment, or from the experiences you go through as you get older and navigate the real world.
    • An example of ideology could be religion. Someone may grow up being taught certain religious beliefs and values that influence how they understand right and wrong and how people should behave. Because these beliefs can be introduced from childhood through family, a person may accept them before having the opportunity to question them or choose what they believe for themselves. Religion can also influence how people view others who do not share the same beliefs, even though identifying with a religion does not automatically make someone a good person, just as not practicing a religion does not make someone a bad person.
    • I also understand ideology as something that can be shaped by a person’s environment, social class, race, gender, culture, and lived experiences. Because people experience the same society differently, they may develop very different beliefs about how society functions and what needs to change. For example, someone raised in a wealthy family may have a different view of economic opportunity in America than someone from a low income, immigrant family who has experienced financial or social barriers. Their different experiences can influence how they view issues such as poverty, government, assistance, immigration, or economic inequality. This helps me understand why people living in the same society can develop very different ideologies.
  2. My understanding of the difference between conservative and liberal ideology in US politics is mostly based on the relationship between the individual and the government. Conservatism generally emphasizes limited government, traditional values, individual responsibility, and a strong national defense. Liberalism generally emphasizes equality, social progress, government responsibility, and using government programs or regulations to address social and economic problems. To me, one of the biggest dividing lines is how much responsibility the government should have for improving people’s lives versus how much responsibility should be placed on individuals.
    • For example, government spending shows this difference. A conservative might support keeping taxes and domestic government spending lower because they believe individuals, families, businesses, and private organizations should have more responsibility and control over their money. Conservatives also view national defense as one of the federal government’s most important responsibilities and usually support strong military spending. A liberal may be willing to pay more taxes and use government funding for important programs such as healthcare, food assistance, education, or affordable housing because they believe the government has a responsibility to reduce inequality and provide a basic level of support for everyone. The disagreement mainly stems from the role the government should play in solving these problems.
    • The main keywords on the conservative side are limited government, individual responsibility, traditional values, and national defense. These ideas usually emphasize less government involvement in people’s lives and the economy, personal responsibility for one’s own success, preserving traditional institutions and values, and maintaining a strong military to protect the country. On the other hand, I associate liberalism with equality, social progress, government responsibility, and a social safety net. These concepts reflect the belief that government can help create more equal opportunities, adapt laws and institutions as society changes, and provide support like food assistance, healthcare, or other resources for people who may need them.
  3. After watching the video, I understand Althusser’s definition of ideology as not something we exactly choose to believe, but something we experience and live through every day, which is how I would personally define it. Institutions and everyday practices help shape how we understand society, what we consider normal, and even how we see ourselves and our place in this world. We may feel like we personally developed our beliefs, but institutions like schools, families, religion, and the media can influence those beliefs from an early age
    • I would use school as a good example because students learn more than just academic subjects. They also learn expectations like being on time, respecting authority, completing assigned work, meeting deadlines, and being rewarded or disciplined based on their behavior. Over time, these practices can teach us what society considers a “good” student or successful person. A student may start to see themselves as either successful or unsuccessful, smart or irresponsible, based on how they are treated within that school system. This shows you Althusser’s idea that ideology works everyday through institutions and experiences that shape how people understand themselves and society.

Discussion 3.1 – Luna Liang

1. My Understanding of Ideology


Ideology isn’t just a set of opinions people hold. It’s more like an invisible framework that tells us what counts as normal, what counts as fair, and what counts as simply “the way things are.” Most of the time we don’t even notice it, because it feels like common sense rather than a belief system.

A good example is how people explain poverty. Someone within a capitalist ideology might say poverty comes from laziness. Someone else might point instead to unfair wages and a system stacked against certain groups. Neither person feels like they’re applying an “ideology.” Each just feels like they’re stating the obvious.

That’s the deeper point: ideology doesn’t feel optional. It shapes the laws we accept and the goals we set for our own lives, while convincing us these are our own free conclusions. It can even make two opposite views of the same problem feel equally natural, which is exactly why it’s so hard to question.

2. Conservative and liberal Ideology in US Politics


If I had to name the word that separates conservative and liberal ideology, it would be liberty versus equality.

For conservatives, liberty means individual and economic freedom. A large government is seen as dangerous because high taxes and regulation limit personal choice, which is why conservatives favor lower spending and traditional values.

Liberals start from equality instead. Government involvement is seen as a tool to correct imbalances the free market creates on its own, through civil rights protections, regulation, and social programs.

  • Healthcare shows this divide clearly. Conservatives push back against government-run healthcare, worried about taxes and lost choice. Liberals support it, arguing affordable care is a basic right, not something tied to income.

3. Althusser’s Definition of Ideology


Althusser described ideology as the system of ideas through which we experience everyday life, not something we consciously choose, but something we live inside without realizing it. He claimed ideology “hails” us, meaning it calls out to us and gets us to see ourselves as free individuals making our own choices. The catch is that this feeling of freedom is exactly what keeps the existing system running.

Based on the course material, Althusser points to schools and media as key ideological state apparatuses. From a young age, school teaches discipline and respect for authority, not through force, but by making obedience feel normal.

  • A simple example is someone staying late at work to earn a promotion. They feel like this is their own decision. But according to Althusser, this is ideology working well: the person believes they’re acting freely, while their unpaid overtime quietly benefits an employer who depends on that labor. The system doesn’t need to force anyone. It just needs people to want to.

 

Zenclaire Jones-Russell- Understanding Ideology

  1. What is ideology?

Ideology is the way we all see the world through our own lens with our beliefs, values and morals. What we choose to believe in shapes us into who we are and what we represent whether people agree or not. When it comes to getting you to stray away from those beliefs, you need fear and ideology. For example, the government uses the police force with threats, the courts and the prisons. When we protest, guess who’s present? The police. When things go wrong and you’re imprisoned, the judge decides your fate with no regard to your ideologies. Anytime you go against social norms and they label you crazy for saying certain beliefs, now you’re a conspiracy theorist which alerts the government. People that do research or become whistleblowers are eliminated or silenced from continuing to speak against the opposition to protect the beliefs that uphold this society we call home. The school systems teach us from young about politics and the areas of socialization, from history glamorizing America to the authority of structure. School just sets us up for the work force that we join at a later time. We have routines and rules we must follow so we can continue to be a law-abiding citizen in this hierarchical society. This is where we learn to function outside of our families. Ideology is just that. A set of beliefs that make you who you are.

2. Conservatives differ from Liberals.

The difference between conservatives and liberal view points in the United States is the conservatives lean more towards a weaker government with less spending which leads to lower taxes, a strong defense and a free market whereas liberals value a bigger government with cuts to military spending and equality.

3. How do I understand Althusser’s definition of Ideology?

The repressive apparatus controls you with the use of courts, prisons and the police whereas ideological apparatuses is the prevention of changing things through school, the media and politics. This keeps the status quo which you maintain control within a society.

Aaron Sierra – What is Ideology?

  1. What Ideology means to me?

    Ideology is a set of beliefs a person has that is stemmed from their socioeconomic background but also from their personal experiences in life. This can be seen clearly when comparing people from different economic backgrounds. Imagine you were raised in a wealthy household. You may come to believe that success is the result of hard work. You may come to realize that you lived someone else’s dream. Now imagine the opposite. You are raised in a low income household. You may come to believe that your community’s hard work is not recognized and that the system is unfair. You may also come to believe that people are lazy. Both of these people are looking at success and poverty, but due to socioeconomic divisions, each will come to a different conclusion on the reasons for these disparities.

    People don’t realize they have an ideology, and as a result, ideology can feel like a truth that everyone can see, as opposed to a belief. People from all economic backgrounds view their outlook on life as the truth. The first example was of a wealthy person. That person doesn’t believe what they have is their ideology. They believe what they have is their worldview. The second example is from a person with a low economic background. They call what they have the truth, and like the wealthy person, they do not believe that it is their ideology they are explaining.
  2. Conservative vs Liberal

    Conservatives and liberals have similar outlooks on the role of the government, but differ greatly on individual responsibility. Conservatives view individual success and failure as the consequence of their efforts and actions. As a result, they favor a small government when it comes to supporting individual economic needs. Whereas, they advocate for a larger government when dealing with issues of law and social order. Liberals support a governmental solution to productive and economic inequity, believing the social and economic injustices caused by factors out of peoples’ control should be addressed by the government. While liberals support the active role of government in issues of productive and economic inequity, they are generally in favor of the restriction of government in social issues, including social order and social justice. For example healthcare: A conservative would argue that the government should not be involved in healthcare, as the government would negatively impact the costs and choices involved. A liberal, however, would argue that government healthcare would ensure that the basic and social need of individuals for healthcare is not neglected.

  3. Althusser’s View on Ideology

    Althusser believes ideology consists of things people believe that they are not even aware of. This belief is not because of their own efforts, it happens almost automatically. For example schools play their part and teach people how to perceive themselves and their social position before they have even learnt how to think about these issues critically. He refers to this as interpellation. This is when society allocates someone a role and the person Allocated that role accepts and we as a society accept that a particular ideology has determined that role.

Ben Y’Barbo – Ideology

1. From the readings, ideology is a system of values and beliefs that shape how people understand their own sociopolitical landscape. This system, for the individual, is foundationally  established early in life (but can grow and change throughout their life), and tends to justify and maintain the status quo.

Gender roles is an example we’ve all personally experienced. During childhood, many of us are taught things like, “boys don’t cry”, “girls play with tea sets and dolls, boys play sports and with action figures”, and “women are better with children”. Although there has been a push for change in recent years in many of these respects, for the majority, it is the natural and expected outcome for men to work in specific career fields, while their wives are steered toward more nurturing fields (assuming they work outside the home at all).

Marx used Western feudalism to explain how we internalize the ruling ideology. The King was King because God ordained it; the serfs were serfs because they believed in the same divine order. For generations, a child saw their father go to work, and their mother take care of the house; their mother sit for tea and their father go hunting. For them, this was the natural order, the ideology is ingrained and there was no reason to question or change the status quo.

2. In the initial “Crash Course” video, the difference between conservative and liberal ideology is very binary in small vs big government and liberty vs equality. In the reading, “Democracy for the Few,” we see that in practice, the trend tends to be more profit and moral driven interference vs equality of protection. Liberals want government intervention to address the economic and social imbalances. On the other hand, conservatives want minimal government intervention in successful business ventures and profits, as well as for many social programs, but will support intervention if those social programs go counter to their morals.

You can see this in action in a more liberal state like New York that has the one of the highest statewide minimum wages, Medicaid spending, and funding for abortion providers and reproductive health; while in the more conservative state Texas, the statewide minimum wage is the federal minimum wage, there is no corporate income tax, as well as tax breaks depending on sector, and is one of 13 total-ban (with exceptions) abortion states.

3. Althusser believed Ideology, or more specifically the capitalist ideology, operates through total interpellation before one is conscious or capable of questioning. Between school, media, family and politics individuals are behaviorally reinforced to recognize their specific role and act accordingly. Reinforcing the totality, even so-called rebellion occurs only through the approved channels, helping maintain the status quo.

In school, students are taught to defer to and obey the authority of the teacher. That authority teaches individuals when and how to do assignments, when to arrive and leave, becoming habits of obedience that will be carried into the workforce.

What is Ideology

Ideology is a set of beliefs and values that shapes how people perceive society and how they think it should operate. It includes a person’s views on government, the economy, religion, gender roles, crime, education, work, and social inequality. Ideology influences what people see as fair, normal, possible, or important. Factors such as family, school, friends, media, and broader culture all play a role in forming and reinforcing a person’s ideology.

For example, someone raised in a family and community that emphasizes individual responsibility, limited government, and free-market economics may grow up believing that success is mostly about hard work and personal choices. This person might see low taxes and minimal regulation as fair and natural, and view poverty primarily as a result of individual failure. In contrast, someone raised in an environment that stresses collective responsibility, social programs, and economic equality may see the same issues differently. They might view poverty as largely shaped by structural factors like unequal access to education or jobs, and support higher taxes on the wealthy to fund public services. Both people are using an ideology to interpret the world, but their ideologies lead them to very different conclusions about what is just and what policies should be pursued.

liberal vs conservative

The main difference between liberal and conservative ideologies is the amount of involvement the government plays in society. Conservative ideology favors limited government, lower taxes, less regulation, and emphasizes individual responsibility and traditional values, while liberal ideology supports a more active government that regulates the economy, provides social services, and works to reduce inequality. 

Althusser’s definition

Althusser’s definition of ideology to me meant that ideology is not just a set of political ideas, but a system that shapes who we are and how we relate to our real conditions of life by making the social order feel natural and unquestionable. He argues that ideology creates an “imaginary relationship” between individuals and their real conditions of existence, meaning it gives people a story about the world that hides or justifies inequality and power.

Yectlanesi Irigoyen Cadena – Ideology

1. My Understanding of Ideology

For me, ideology is a set of beliefs and values that shape how a person sees the world. These beliefs can come from how we were raised, our experiences, and the people around us, but we can also develop or change our own beliefs.

For example, two people may have different opinions about vaccines. One may believe they are helpful, while another may believe they are harmful. Their different beliefs can come from their experiences, background, or the information they have learned.That doesnt mean one is right and then the other isn’t. I just understand that every opinion comes from the way they were influenced.

I think ideology can change over time because people can learn new things and hear different perspectives. This can change how they think about society, government, education, and other issues.

2. Conservative and Liberal Ideology

For me, the main difference between conservative and liberal ideology is how they view government, equality, and social change. Conservatives tend to value tradition, individual responsibility, religion, and limited government, while liberals tend to focus more on social equality, government support, and social change. For example, when it comes to poverty, conservatives may focus more on individual responsibility, while liberals may focus more on how people who are disadvantaged may need support from the government. I think this difference in how they view equality and social change is one of the main dividing lines between conservatives and liberals.

 3. Althusser’s Definition of Ideology

I understand Althusser’s definition of ideology as the idea that our beliefs and the way we see the world are shaped by society. We can be influenced by our family, school, religion, and other parts of society. For example, children can learn their parents’ beliefs at home and learn different ideas at school. But I believe as they grow older, they may begin to question these beliefs and decide what they believe for themselves. In my opinion, this shows that society can shape our ideology, but our beliefs can also change as we have new experiences and learn different perspectives.