Discussion Board Prompt #6

Post and Comment on Discussion Board #6
  • Post due Thursday 10/8
  • Comment due Sunday 10/11

For this week’s post, please analyze the two sample literature reviews you read. For each literature review, answer the following questions (same as above):

  • What is the thesis, research question, or problem that the literature review addresses? (What is the purpose of the literature review?)  Be specific- quote the article.
  • What do the authors do? What type of literature do they review? Do they review literature in a particular field or discipline?
  • What does the literature review find? You may want to look at how it is organized (e.g. headings) to analyze the different themes or areas of information that the review contains.
  • What are the gaps or next steps, according to the author?

Alyssa Granderson- DB6

 

  • What is the thesis, research question, or problem that the literature review addresses? (What is the purpose of the literature review?)  Be specific- quote the article.

In the article Paternal Influences on Adolescent Sexual Behavior I believe that the research question is what role do parents have on adolescent sexual behavior. I say this because in the abstract it says, “The objective of this study was to conduct a structured review to assess the role of paternal influence on adolescent sexual behavior and to assess the methodological quality of the paternal influence literature related to adolescent sexual behavior.”

In the article Gender Identity in European Family Farming it stats in the first paragraph “This paper is concerned with representation of gender in research texts. It uses the research literature on gender in family farming as study material in order to pinpoint meanings of gender in the academic literature.”

 

  • What do the authors do? What type of literature do they review? Do they review literature in a particular field or discipline?

 

Vincent Guilamo-Ramos is employed in the Silver School of Social Work and Center for Latino Adolescent and Family Health along with Jane Lee and Katherine McCarthy. Alida Bouris is employed at the School of Social Administration. And Shannon L. Michael, Seraphine Pitt-Barnes, and Patricia Dittus is employed in Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. I think this literature was in a particular field because this study was in a particular field.

 

 

In the article Gender Identity in European Family Farming. The author, Berit Brandth focuses on the literature based on rural gender studies and agricultural media mainly for analysis. I think this literature was discipline because of the format it is written in.

 

  • What does the literature review find? You may want to look at how it is organized (e.g. headings) to analyze the different themes or areas of information that the review contains.

In the article Paternal Influences on Adolescent Sexual Behavior the authors searched 6 databases for keywords of adolescent sexual behavior and parenting processes were identified. There were 4 main points for the literature they reviewed, 1- articles were prereview between 1980-2011, 2- adolescents were living in the U.S ages 11-18, 3- examined adolescent sexual behaviors or reproductive outcomes, and 4- focused on paternal parenting processes. The conclusions from the study were that fathers have the potential to uniquely influence adolescent sexual behavior, but it is overlooked.

In the article Gender Identity in European Family Farming. I believe that the findings are that farm women’s main strategy is loyalty to ensure the survival of the family farm.

 

 

  • What are the gaps or next steps, according to the author?

I’m not sure what the findings for article Gender Identity in European Family Farming. In Paternal Influences on Adolescent Sexual Behavior the next steps would be that the fathers influence the sexual behavior on their children. Which is understandable because from the finding fathers do play a role in adolescent sexual behavior.

 

 

Loronda Johnson DB 6

Paternal Influences on Adolescent Sexual Risk Behaviors: A Structured Literature Review

  • What is the thesis, research question, or problem that the literature review addresses? (What is the purpose of the literature review?)  Be specific- quote the article.

The article stated,  “the objective of this study was to conduct a strictest review to assess the role of paternal influence on adolescent sexual behavior and to assess the methodological quality of the paternal influence literature related to adolescent sexual behavior.”

  • What do the authors do? What type of literature do they review? Do they review literature in a particular field or discipline?

Vincent Guilamo-Ramos is employed in the Silver School of Social Work and Center for Latino Adolescent and Family Health along with Jane Lee and Katherine McCarthy which is located at New York University in New York. Alida Bouris is employed at the School of Social Administration which is located in the University of Chicago at Chicago, Illinois. And Shannon L. Michael, Seraphine Pitt-Barnes, and Patricia Dittus is employed in Centers for Disease Control and Prevention which located at Atlanta, Georgia. The type of literature they reviewed is about mainly social work with adolescents along with medical care issues. I believe that they review literature in a particular field because based on the degrees they achieved, it’s best to say that they know the certain fields that they went to universities for their intended majors.

  • What does the literature review find? You may want to look at how it is organized (e.g. headings) to analyze the different themes or areas of information that the review contains.

Based on the literature review, the authors used methodological research by searching electronic databases. And according to the studies they founded, between 1980 and 2011, targeted adolescents between ages 11 to 18 years old and focused on the paternal parenting processes. It was assessed by an 11 scoring system. And for the results based on the methods they used, they found that paternal factors are associated with sexual behavior related to maternal factors. The most common was emotional qualities on the father-adolescent relationship. The communication was associated within the behavior while fathers attitude were less associated.

  • What are the gaps or next steps, according to the author?

According to the authors, the next steps suggested that the fathers influence the sexual behavior on their children. But more research suggested diverse facets of paternal influence on sexual behavior is needed. And the authors are providing recommendations from the primary care providers and practitioners to better influence fathers to intervene into their children lives to reduce their sexual behavior.

Gender Identity in European Family Farming 

  • What is the thesis, research question, or problem that the literature review addresses? (What is the purpose of the literature review?)  Be specific- quote the article.

According to the article, it stated that “paper is concerned with representation of gender in research texts. It uses the research literature on gender in family farming as study material in order to pinpoint meanings of gender in the academic literature.”

  • What do the authors do? What type of literature do they review? Do they review literature in a particular field or discipline?

The author, Berit Brandth focuses on the literature based on rural gender studies but also focused on the agricultural media mainly for analysis. I think that Brandth reviewed literature in a discipline matter because of the research he did and the review that’s being read.

  • What does the literature review find? You may want to look at how it is organized (e.g. headings) to analyze the different themes or areas of information that the review contains.

The literature review resulted in gender in agriculture presented with a complex and mixed social configuration. The author use three discourses in order to find his results within his research all compromise in the same discursive order, gender in agriculture.

  • What are the gaps or next steps, according to the author?

According to the article, the author discussed the conclusion involving the discourses he use to find his results which was examined by the fight for hegemony and the interplay between the discourses.