Author Archives: Kat Gawin

Discussion #3 ,Kat Gawin, “Privilege & Oppression”

  • In what ways do you experience privilege?

I experienced privilege in life when I looked for a job at age 24 in New York. I didn’t speak English, I didn’t have any experience, and I would just walk from restaurant to restaurant asking if I can be a hostess or a waitress. I was hired , even though there were American college graduate students and a woman of color next to me. I was shocked. One of my friends with a black associated name told me my name sounds white so my resume might be picked up before someone else’s. I felt horrible but it was a privilege I didn’t know was attached to me. I also recognized how privileged I was in The United States because of my European education and how much my parents invested in me. To be raised by both parents is a huge privilege !I was very privileged as an emigrant, even though I had to struggle to fit in and adjust to my new life. 

  • In what ways do you experience oppression?

I felt oppressed being harassed by older men trying to be too friendly with me. My mother taught me to speak up in situations like that so I did many times. Men would approach me often in many ways, and I never felt comfortable, and I would be scared. So I was insulting and unpleasant to them. I felt oppressed at home because I was raised with three brothers, and they were the solid structure of the family in the conversations. If they had good grades, they would be praised for intelligence and awarded. If I would get good grades, I will be a girl who studies well as every girl should. My housework was never appreciated, and my efforts were very obvious in a household because this is what women do in polish society. I was also treated very unfairly by my ex-husband, who wanted me to be a housewife, and I was not allowed to have male friends. He would decide if we go for a trip or if we go out that weekend or not. I had to say yes to many rules he had, and I didn’t agree. So I left one day …

Reflection #3 Kat Gawin “Privilege & Oppression”

Having a home, water, and perhaps electricity is a fundamental human right, and you die without it or live an impossible life. Yet, not everyone has it.

World is an unfair, cruel place, and it’s heartbreaking to know how many children live in poor living conditions, how a recent earthquake in Turkey demolished thousands of lives, and how wars affect people who suffer tremendously, losing everything!Do we feel lucky  seeing this?  I feel privileged that these disasters never happened in my life.I feel for people.  I try to help when I can. My family decided to let Ukrainian families live in our place in Poland. But that is still very little help. I live here in the United States, work and go to college, but others try to stay alive. When I say, I take one day at a time to survive, in my reality, others run from bombs! Nevertheless, every problem has value, and we also prepare this country for those who will survive wars, our children here,veterans and everyone who is here so that they can live good  life.

My daughter is a person of color. I have known her father for many years. I was exposed to a massive injustice that affected my partner’s life, and I was sometimes afraid for his life. Knowing how many issues people of color experience makes me see how little we understand of human value. And how ugly it is to see racist comments toward people who built this country as enslaved people!! Reading Peggy McIntosh White Privilege: Unpacking the Invisible Knapsack” made me recognize how many little knife-stabbing situations one can experience beyond what I already knew. 

A day for me can be so dramatically different than a person of color, and we will go through the same situations. The list of 25 white privileges is very serious, and some of them are mind-opening, like the thrift shop clothing, newspapers with people of my race, cash in my pocket, or a neighborhood etc. Peggy McIntosh is very honest, and that shows that admitting to doing something wrong is ok. I guess that’s how you change. She is very clear, and her writing sounds a bit like a confession. 

In Meryline Frye article, I strongly agree with what she called being oppressed. To expect a woman to smile is to push her( make her) not to complain and to accept what you have, no matter what you think. A woman who is speaking her mind is difficult to work with! How wrong and unfair this is. The comparison to a bird in a cage is very accurate. The cage shows the macroscopic phenomenon of pretending to have a good life but in real-life situations, the laws are taken away! You are praised if you are in control if your freedom to fly and be is taken away. You are a symbol of beauty to smile and obey, you are a mother or wife to place a role of a family member, and if you like to work without acceptance of a man, you are not a good family member, you aren’t a good mother.

Fake behavior covers the truth under the night. Opening a door by a gentleman seems fancy, but he might not obey that person’s fundamental rights in another situation.

I don’t like the word LADY, and I learn how not to use it anymore. I think it was made by men to control women. What is LAdy ???

Discussion #2 Kat Gawin

What does it mean to move beyond the gender binary for Alok?

Alok explains how gender feels from a perspective of a non-conforming gender person. That gives us access to be closer to someone’s experience and be more sensitive about details of non-conforming people’s problems. We live in a world where everything is set in stone; we didn’t learn to think otherwise. The gender norms are based on the old way of thinking- very old where masculine is for men, and being feminine is only for women. We are not only men or women, calm or hyper, strong or weak. Alok shows a life of a regular person whose rights are taken away because he feet to old school, wrong standards and laws and typical education is not updated.

He explains how not understanding gender takes human rights away. Alok writes examples in people’s behavior and stereotypes of thinking that create problems with work discrimination, school bullying, mental health problems, and even lack of housing and homelessness. 

Tolerance seems not enough because it only gives some of the rights to a person. Acceptance will put the person into life fully. 

Alok points out that since 2015 there have been 1.4 billion transgender people. That’s a huge number. How many people might not be comfortable showing their identity? That’s a fact and not a trend but a situation that should make us reflect and allow being better, smarter, and more compassionate people. They show how important it is for people to state their gender and gives an example of how gender is visible all the time and we don’t pay attention: to a birth certificate, driver’s licenses, stores, etc.

Alok represents transgender men and women in his writing; I find this interesting and inspiring.  

In what ways does your gender identity go against the binary norm, and in what ways does it fit the binary norm?

I am a binary woman who identifies as she/her. I was raised in an extremely catholic country, Poland but by not ordinary parents. My father was an extreme introvert, a painter and poet, the most tolerant person you can imagine. My mom was a very masculine lawyer focused on her career. Strong and very beautiful, never interested in cooking and raising her children. I was raised by a mysterious grandmother at home, and both of my partners would bring day stores at 8pm or 9pm pm at night to eat a quick dinner with their children. We were not religious at all. We valued morality based on actions and internal existential dialog. My dinner table conversations were about children’s rights and domestic abuse because my mom spoke the most. 

The gender rules in my family were not typical. Now that I am older, I see what family is and what could possibly be bad or good in building a family structure, and it is not what Polish education told me!

I would wear men’s clothes and have short hair my entire childhood because I had brothers, and in a communist occupied by Russians Poland no one cared about colors and dresses. I felt solid and feminine riding my bike and being a police officer, and I would have a crash in elementary school with a most popular and probably not exciting boy. I kissed girls in high school, read Rilke, and shaved my head boldly, always thinking I was very feminine this way. I was skinny, wearing only black clothes at 20, and did not have visible breasts till I was 30, also thinking that I was feminine that way. Some of that stuff wasn’t feminine in typical stereotypical thinking. I always wanted a child, loved my soft, delicate boyfriend, and always went to gay parties In Riss beach and Henrietta club, also with a feminine attitude.

I am sure if I fell in love with a woman, nothing would stop me from being with her, and I would call myself, or maybe I am, a bisexual woman. It just did not happen; It has not happened yet. I wonder if I am not binary identifying as a woman. I am a single mother by choice. I was the only one supporting my family (my mother and brother ). Is that masculine? Is that feminine to pay all the bills ? 

I worked in a butcher store. I constantly interrupt men and women in conversations. Is that masculine? 

Reading reflection #2 Kat Gawin “Beyond the Gender Binary”

Alok’s book “Beyond the Gender Binary” discusses understanding what gender is. It allows us to get closer to facts about how gender forms and their fluidity. His writing shows how people think, why they don’t understand who others are, and how people perceive the world in everyday situations where they are being misunderstood and judged. Alok explains that society’s rules are built on stereotypes and straightforward structures based on very little we know or assume. I can compare this to the medieval discovery of Copernicus that placed the Sun in the center, and people could not believe it at first. The Earth is not flat, and the Sun does not circle us. We are not born one man and woman only, and we do not need to stick to the birth certificate label for the rest of our lives.

Alok’s writing made me sad. I am not a revolutionary leader type, but I like to wonder how people feel! My empathy goes far, and understanding his words makes me see how much people suffer. It is unfortunate when Alok explains how transgender people do not exist in society in others’ perceptions. How, then, can people analyze, and build laws and health coverage, for someone they “don’t believe in ”, they don’t acknowledge, something that they do not accept- they reject—nonbinary people? It is discrimination. It takes human rights away and blocks access to methal care, social life, and even safety. Again, it is sad that we need to explain basic human rights to ignorants. Let’s go deeper and imagine that the world is all men and women are not women but “men-less’ creatures. And we need to prove, demonstrate and fight to show men that they are not the only gender. It sounds like science fiction. So for non-binary people, the reality they see is a false reality. Moreover, the wrong perspective builds unfair rights that punish non-binary people! Religion wants to eliminate them, and politics creates a colossal problem of citizens’ right to be. The culture is not flexible. We should pray in universities for education, not in churches for blessings. We would know that living beyond the gender binary isn’t a new thing. We should know that word is not a symbol of 2 -there is not only masculine and feminine. Not only one or the other. It is not an illness or a disorder.