Rena Korb, a scholar, examines many ways to understand “Where Are You Going, Where Have You Been?” in her critical analysis. According to one interpretation cited in the essay by Korb, the tale is essentially a “inverted fairy tale.” According to this view, Connie, the main character, is a contemporary Cinderella who is tempted into leaving her comfortable home and entering a perilous world.
This perspective, in Korb’s opinion, is supported by a number of the story’s features. Arnold Friend, for instance, can be compared to a dark prince or other bad character who tempts Connie with the prospect of freedom and adventure. Similar to Connie, Arnold’s eventual dominance over her can be seen as her falling under his enchantment or spell.
This interpretation intrigues me personally since it brings out the story’s fundamental elements of vulnerability and innocence. Connie is initially portrayed as a young girl stuck between childhood and adulthood, much like Cinderella. She longs for freedom and adventure but lacks the knowledge to avoid the dangers that lie ahead.
This perspective also clarifies the expectations that society has for young women. In “Where Are You Going, Where Have You Been?” Connie is shown as a man’s object of desire who is the victim of male manipulation, much like how women are frequently portrayed in traditional fairy tales as damsels in distress waiting for their prince charming to save them.
Overall, understanding “Where Are You Going, Where Have You Been?” as an upside-down fairy tale helps us comprehend its themes and characters better. It serves as a warning about the dangers young women must avoid in a world where outward appearances can be deceitful
2 thoughts on “Melissa Cruz week 5”
I really got stuck when you called Connie a contemporary Cinderella because I do not see the comparison. Connie is nothing like Cinderella. Connie is not treated like a maid and cinderella wasn’t full of herself . Connie just has an ordinary teenage mentality . Her family does not leave her out of family events, she is the one that removes herself because she doesn’t want to be around her family like any other teenager. Connie seeks male validation but Cinderella doesnt, Cinderella wants the same treatment as her sisters and just happens to get the man. I just do not think they are valid to compare.
Elizabeth, I appreciate this thoughtful and civil disagreement with a colleague. You make your point and back it up with examples from both stories.