The theme in the nineteenth-century Emily Dickinson’s poem “The Wife” connects with the twentieth-century story “Another Evening at the Club” by Alifa Rifaat because it mentions the gender norms during that time. In “Another Evening at the Club,” mentions how this young teenage girl, Samia, ends up getting married to a wealthy older man. Her mom prepared her to become a wife by doing work at home while she was still in middle school. Samia started to question whether the servant knew where her missing bracket was. So, the husband took matters into his hands and slapped her which shows power when there’s a disagreement between a man and a woman. Salma could’ve said something and stopped him from hitting the servant but no she was just standing there. But later on, Salma finds the bracelet, and the husband doesn’t care enough to drop the charges because he doesn’t want the town to laugh at them. The quote “To take honorable work, of woman and of wife” by Emily Dickinson connects with Samia’s life because she as a woman must look beautiful, do wife duties, and agree with any decisions her husband makes. This entitles her to have no say. Her husband is the man of the house and is right in everything. Emily Dickinson and Alifa Rifaat both give an example of gender norms during those times and sadly it’s still happening to this day.
One thought on “Anayeli Maximino Discussion 2”
I agreed with a lot you had to say about the stories and why the themes connect. In my response I also expressed how Samia’s parents prepped and arranged for her to be married, despite her wanting to go to school and further her education. I said at that moment it showed how male dominance was present heavily around these times, specifically in situations like this. Despite Samia bringing up the missing jewelry to her husband without any proof beforehand, it wasn’t up to him to put his hands on her, but of course this was normal back then. Samia should’ve knew that he was going to flex his masculinity around. To conclude, I was pretty shocked when she tried to do the right thing by going to tell her husband she found the missing item and it was could’ve possibly been her fault. The husband was absolutely wrong in not allowing Gazia to be released for a crime she didn’t commit, but of course he wanted to be seen as perfect and that was bad on his name. I felt like Samia could’ve done more on her part as well instead of following through, but the again have to think about the times and how they were already treated, she really had no other options her in case.