The moral dilemma in “Leave No Trace” arises from the conflict between Will’s desire for complete independence from society and his daughter Tom’s growing recognition of the benefits of social integration and community support.
Will, suffering from PTSD and haunted by his experiences in the war, prefers to live in isolation in the woods, away from the rules and expectations of society. He believes this lifestyle is the best way to protect himself and Tom from the dangers and constraints of the outside world. On the other hand, Tom, although initially content with their unconventional lifestyle, begins to appreciate the warmth and support of the community they encounter when they are taken in by social services and later by the trailer community.
- I would follow my conscience: Will might feel that his conscience demands he live a life of complete self-reliance and isolation, prioritizing his own mental well-being and sense of freedom.
- I don’t know what I would do: Will’s decision might be clouded by uncertainty, especially considering the conflicting desires for independence and the well-being of his daughter.
- I would do whatever would improve my own situation: This position might lead Will to prioritize his own comfort and avoidance of societal norms, regardless of the impact on Tom.
- I Would Do What God or the Scriptures Say Is Right: Will interpret his actions as aligning with a sense of divine guidance, particularly if he views his independence as a form of self-preservation mandated by a higher power.
- I Would Do Whatever Made Me Happy: Will’s decision could be driven by his pursuit of personal happiness, which he associates with a life of solitude in the wilderness.
- I would follow the advice of an authority figure: Will might follow the advice of social workers, educators, or medical professionals who advocate for integration into society for Tom’s well-being.
- I would do what’s best for everyone: This position would prioritize the overall well-being and happiness of both Will and Tom, considering the long-term effects of their choices on their mental and physical health, as well as their relationships with others.
I would prioritize what’s best for everyone involved. While I understand Will’s desire for autonomy and his struggle with PTSD, I would recognize that Tom’s well-being and development are equally important. Integration into society offers her opportunities for growth, education, and socialization. She shows her enjoyment of being near people and her disagreement with Will to stay away from society.
When making this decision, I considered the feelings and perspectives of both Will and Tom. In this situation, the desires of one person should not cross the rights and boundaries of another. Will mostly focused on his perception of the world and hoped that Tom would accept it without question. However, she is a separate person and cannot live according to his vision forever. If he continued to force her to live his previous life with him, it would be very selfish of Will. At the same time, it would be torture for Tom to force her father to change against his will. He is a grown man who can take care of himself and decide what to do with his life.
