Summary
In "Moonlight," Juan, a drug dealer who becomes a father figure to Chiron, faces a tough choice. He wants to help and protect Chiron, but his illegal activities and Chiron's drug-using mom make things complicated.
The possible outcomes of this dilemma via the 7 moral positions:
1. Follow my conscience: Juan might feel bad about his actions and decide to help Chiron despite the risks.
2. I don’t know what I would do**: Juan could feel unsure about what to do because he cares about Chiron but also needs to stay safe.
3. Improve my own situation: Juan might keep selling drugs to stay safe and make money, even if it hurts Chiron.
4. Do what God or the Scriptures say is right: If Juan is religious, he might try to be a better person by helping Chiron and quitting his illegal job.
5. Do whatever makes me happy: Juan might feel happy helping Chiron, so he chooses to support him even if it's hard.
6. Follow the advice of an authority figure: Juan could ask Teresa or someone he trusts for advice on how to help Chiron while staying safe.
7. Do what’s best for everyone: Juan might think about what's good for Chiron and their community and decide to stop selling drugs to be a better role model for Chiron.
In Juan's situation, I would decide to help Chiron because he needs someone to support him, and I want to do what's best for him. Even though it might be tough, I believe it's important to prioritize Chiron's well-being and offer him guidance and protection.
In Juan's situation, I decided to help Chiron because it seemed like the right thing to do. My choice was based on the idea of doing what's best for him. Based on this analysis, I feel confident in my moral compass. I believe in prioritizing the well-being of others and doing what's right, even when it's challenging. My decision-making is guided by a sense of responsibility and empathy toward those who need support. Overall, I try to make choices that support with my values and contribute positively to the lives of others.
One thought on “Khar’s conversation 8”
Hi, Khan! I like your post. Your analysis of Juan’s predicament in “Moonlight” demonstrates a deep understanding of the moral complexities he faces. You’ve explored the potential outcomes of his dilemma from various ethical perspectives, showing a nuanced grasp of the situation. Your decision to prioritize helping Chiron, despite the risks involved, reflects a strong sense of empathy and moral responsibility. By considering Chiron’s well-being above all else, you emphasize the importance of compassion and support in challenging circumstances. Your reflections on your own moral compass further underscore your principled approach to decision-making. Overall, your comment offers a compelling interpretation of the film’s moral themes and the significance of ethical considerations in personal relationships. Great job!