Skip to content

Units 7 and 8 Discussion #1

Why do people wish to maintain distinctive ways of speaking, even when those ways may be stigmatized?

11 thoughts on “Units 7 and 8 Discussion #1”

  1. Language reflects what is important to those who speak it. In turn, languages adapt as societies grow and change. Language relates common experiences and backgrounds, and these histories, in turn, create words specific to our culture. When languages are lost, culture is lost with them. Historically, culture has often been passed down through oral traditions; stories and lessons passed from generation to generation without much writing.
    Spoken words are an art form, a way for values and traditions to be passed down for generations. When a language is lost, part of that culture is lost. By the same measure, when language is preserved, the traditions and customs continue living in the hearts and minds of those who understand it.
    Maintaining native language allows for more meaningful communication that can facilitate respect for these relationships as well as heritage culture as a whole. Native language maintenance is also an important factor in the retainment of personal identity.
    Language is fundamental to cultural identity. This is so for people everywhere. For this reason, it is important that people keep their own language alive.

  2. Sustaining unique speech patterns despite social disapproval frequently results from a multifaceted interaction between resistance, community, and identity. Language is an essential component of both individual and societal identity, not only a means of communication. Many people find that their distinctive speech pattern reflects their social connections, cultural background, or geographic history. These language traits act as potent markers of identity, bringing people closer to their ancestry and inspiring pride in it. Thus, maintaining unique speech patterns turns into a strategy for demonstrating cultural uniqueness and confirming identity in the face of homogenizing forces.

    Speaking in unique ways can serve as a kind of resistance against social marginalization and linguistic hegemony. There is a hierarchy of prestige associated with language, with some dialects or accents being considered more “correct” or “proper” than others. Speakers of stigmatized speech types may deliberately decide to hold onto them in defiance of prevailing linguistic norms when they are marginalized or disparaged. Individuals assert their individuality and subvert the power dynamics that aim to dictate linguistic authenticity by refusing to adhere to predefined standards.

    In addition, keeping one’s unique speech patterns helps linguistic communities feel united and included. Speakers form ties with one another through shared language traits, which strengthen group identity and promote mutual understanding and support. When speakers encounter bias or discrimination because of their language use, in-group solidarity becomes especially crucial. Through embracing their unique speech patterns, people confirm that they are part of a group that shares their experiences and linguistic background, which gives collective identity power and resilience.

  3. Language is a distinctive way of speaking that showcases our identity, authenticity, cultural community, and resistance to stigma norms. Continuing the dialect of how individuals speak allows one the ability to display cultural backgrounds, personalities, comfort and familiarity. Being able to speak freely in the dialect one is comfortable with provides a sense of authenticity, solidarity and shared history when using a familiar dialect.

  4. People stick to their unique ways of speaking even if others look down on them because how we talk is tied closely to who we are. Our language shows where we belong and connects us to our community. Sometimes, talking differently is a way for groups to stick together and feel proud of their shared background. It can also be a quiet rebellion against what’s considered normal. Some folks just feel more comfortable speaking in their own way. And for many, it’s a way to hold onto their cultural roots and celebrate where they come from. So, even if society frowns upon certain ways of speaking, people often keep using them because it’s a big part of who they are.

  5. There are several reasons why people wish to maintain a distinctive way of speaking even when those ways may be stigmatized. When speaking most people often stick to their native language and cultural identity. This can be how they pronounce a word, their dialect, accent etc.

    For instance, I can recall being in conversations with people and they would substitute a word for another word to match their understanding of the story. For example, In America the purple vegetable or fruit is called eggplant. In my mother’s country in South America they call it balanjay but it’s literally the same thing. If I ask someone from my mother’s country if they like eggplant as a dish they would probably ask “what is that” or correct me and say no it balanjay. What they are saying is not incorrect, but it’s their way of cultural language.

    This in contrast also shows how culture can influence language and how we communicate with one another.

    Language overall plays a critical role on how we communicate which in turn effects our behavior. It is important to maintain culture and your native ways of speaking. As this can cause a sense of cultural pride and better understanding of the conversation. Although it may be stigmatized, it’s best to stick to what you know and feel comfortable saying and/ or expressing.

  6. What I noticed in the film American Tongues is that despite certain groups of people being well aware that their particular accent may trigger people to have preconceived notions about them, even discriminate against them, they feel that their speech is a core part of their identity. Many dialects have a long history that is tied to a region or ethnic culture, and people that belong to those regions or ethnic cultures or both may find a sense of pride, comfort, and familiarity in the dialect that they grew up speaking.

  7. People often wish to maintain distinctive ways of speaking for several reasons, even if those ways are stigmatized by others. Certain dialects or accents are associated with specific regions, social groups, or communities. For individuals, maintaining their distinctive way of speaking can be a way to preserve their cultural heritage and sense of belonging. People within a particular community may use shared language features to reinforce bonds and establish insider status. This can create a sense of cohesion and mutual understanding among group members. Language can also function as a form of social signaling. By using distinctive speech patterns, individuals may signal their membership in particular social groups or their alignment with certain values or ideologies.

  8. People often wish to keep their distinctive ways of speaking, even when stigmatized, due to the deep connection between language and identity. Language is not only a tool for communication it serves as an important tool for one’s social identity, community belonging, and cultural heritage. When a particular way of speaking is stigmatized, it may be associated with minority groups within society. In such cases, individuals who identify with those groups may consciously or unconsciously cling to their distinctive speech patterns as a form of resistance against dominant cultural norms. Maintaining their unique language can be a way to let their identity be known and to affirm their belonging to a particular community, and preserve cultural heritage in the face of external pressure to assimilate. Additionally, for some individuals, the stigmatized language may hold personal or emotional significance, representing familiarity, comfort, and authenticity. Despite the social stigma attached to certain ways of speaking, individuals may choose to preserve them as a of letting it be known of their identity, resisting assimilation, and maintaining a sense of belonging and authenticity.

  9. Although certain linguistic features are perceived negatively, the main reason why people still choose to speak the way they do, is because language can be used as a way to identify yourself. Language holds value to the person who speaks it. Stigmatization can lead to prejudice and discrimination. Some people would change their language for the sake of social status, and others will use it as an opportunity to show their identity because it gives them value.

  10. People wish to maintain distinctive ways of speaking, due to it serving a signal of belonging to a particular group or community. By speaking in a certain way, individuals can express solidarity with others who share their dialect or accent, fostering a sense of belonging and connection. The feeling of belonging in a community is important to many people
    Furthermore, Culture and identity are closely linked to language. A person’s cultural background can be identified by their distinctive languages or accents. Individuals who want to keep their cultural identity may be proud of their linguistic background and want to see it preserved.

Leave a Reply