As a psychology student, I would analyze The Lesson by focusing on Sylvia’s development and the emotional relationship between the kids rather than the big social issues. I think Sylvia’s sarcastic and tough personality is just a mechanism to protect herself from feeling vulnerable. She feels like Miss Moore is trying to make her feel less than her, which might be the reason she doesn’t like her. In reality, Miss Moore doesn’t force the kids to agree with her. She shows and teaches them things and lets them think for themselves. However, by the end of the story, we see Sylvia starting to think about things differently, even if she doesn’t want to admit it. I would present this in my essay to support my argument on Sylvia’s personal growth. Additionally, Sylvia’s conflict with Sugar would also play an important part in my essay. They’re close, but as Sugar starts to understand what Miss Moore is teaching, Sylvia feels betrayed. This tension shows how growing up can sometimes mean growing apart from people you’re close to. We can tell that Sylvia doesn’t want to be left behind, but she’s not ready to change yet, either. The essay title could be The Journey to Self-Discovery, focusing on how Sylvia’s internal conflict is a key part of the story. It’s less about money and more about how she’s learning, even when she doesn’t want to.
Powered by:
top
3 thoughts on “Diana Gomez – Discussion 3”
Hi Diana, as a psychology student it was interesting to read your view of the story.
Your focus on Sylvia’s emotional development gives another point of view to the story. It’s interesting to see how Sylvia uses her tough, sarcastic exterior as a method to hide her vulnerability, especially in dealings with Miss Moore. The confusion Sylvia experiences when Sugar starts to grasp Miss Moore’s lessons serves as a good metaphor for the challenge of growing up. Sylvia’s internal process towards self-awareness and growth is demonstrated by her dislike to changes, personal conflicts, and fear of falling behind.
Diana, literature class is a great place for your to practice your psychological analysis skills. I think you’ve got Sylvia down quite well in your observation about her tough exterior as a mechanism for self-protection. (Spoken like a true psychologist). Your insights about her anger are also good, and your thesis is clear in its focus on Sylvia’s “internal conflict.”
Your analysis of Sylvia’s growth in “The Lesson” is great. Focusing on her emotions and relationships, instead of just the big social issues, is a nice take. I like how you point out her tough attitude as a way to protect herself and explore her feelings toward Miss Moore and Sugar. The title “The Journey to Self-Discovery” fits Sylvia’s struggles well. By showing her resistance to change and her growing distance from Sugar, you add more meaning to the story.
I wish I could analyze even half as well as you did.