Welcome to Week 12th!
Overview
This week’s exploration into social control theories delves into the intricate balance between innate desires and societal constraints. These theories challenge the traditional view of criminality by suggesting that the propensity for deviant behavior is universal and that compliance with societal norms is a result of external and internal controls rather than a lack of criminal inclination.
We will examine various models within this framework, starting with Travis Hirschi’s Social Bond Theory, which proposes that strong social bonds to family, school, and other societal institutions inhibit deviant behavior. According to Hirschi, elements like attachment, commitment, involvement, and belief play pivotal roles in preventing delinquency.
Additionally, we will look into the Self-Control Theory, introduced by Gottfredson and Hirschi, which posits that low self-control, established in early childhood and influenced by parenting and environment, is a major factor in the propensity towards crime. This theory suggests that individuals with low self-control are more likely to engage in impulsive and risk-seeking behaviors, which are often associated with criminal activities.
We’ll also explore the concept of ‘techniques of neutralization’ by Sykes and Matza, which explains how individuals justify deviant behavior to themselves. This perspective suggests that people drift between criminal and conventional behaviors based on their rationalizations.
Our discussions will include critical perspectives on these theories, examining how they address or neglect issues of power, inequality, and societal structure. We will question the universality of the ‘natural tendency’ towards crime and consider cultural, economic, and social factors that influence both the formation of self-control and societal bonds.
Through a combination of readings, videos, and discussion, we aim to achieve a comprehensive understanding of social control theories and encourage critical thinking about their application and relevance in understanding criminal behavior in contemporary society. This exploration will not only deepen our understanding of why some individuals refrain from crime but also challenge us to think about the broader implications of these theories in shaping criminal justice policies and practices.
Lesson Objectives
By the end of this week, you will be able to:
- Identify the central question of the social control theories.
- Discuss early models of social control theories.
- Identify the four bonds proposed by Travis Hirschi.
- Describe how a low level of self-control leads to delinquency and criminality, based on the General Theory of Crime.
Workflow
Readings
Chapter 10 in Piquero, Alex R. The Handbook of Criminological Theory, edited by Melissa L. Rorie, John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated, 2015. ProQuest Ebook Central
https://ebookcentral.proquest.com/lib/bmcc/reader.action?docID=4035968&ppg=205
Access the chapter here.
The_Handbook_of_Criminological_Theory_-_Pg_205-232Sage Publications (2010). Encyclopedia of Criminological Theory: Hirschi, Travis: Social Control Theory.
Access the chapter here.
Hirschi_Travis_-_Social_Control_Theory-2