Summary
In the movie "The Dark Knight," Batman is faced with the moral dilemma of whether he should reveal his true identity in order to save the life of Rachel Dawes or Harvey Dent.
1. Ethical egoism - Batman would only consider his own interests and would reveal his identity to save Rachel, disregarding any consequences it might have.
2. Utilitarianism - Batman would consider the greatest good for the greatest number of people, which may lead him to reveal his identity to save Rachel as she is an important figure in the city.
3. Deontology - Batman would follow the principle of duty and not reveal his identity, as he made a promise to never reveal his identity to anyone.
4. Virtue ethics - Batman may act based on his own character traits, such as bravery or selflessness, and make the decision that aligns with those traits.
5. Justice - Batman may consider the consequences for the legal system and reveal his identity, as the legal system can better serve justice if those involved have all of the necessary information.
6. Care ethics - Batman may consider the emotional impact on the people around him and make the decision that would cause the least harm to those close to him.
7. Moral relativism - This position would suggest that there is no universal moral value or principle to refer to, and as such, Batman should consider his own beliefs and make the decision that aligns with them.
If I was Batman, I would’ve had to stick to the code and kept my identity secret. Way more complication come once your identity is revealed.
The moral value or principle at stake in this dilemma is the principle of duty or promise-keeping. Batman made a promise to never reveal his identity, and thus he is faced with the moral dilemma of breaking that promise to potentially save Rachel.
Conversation 8
