Jayleen Abreu DB 7.1

The role of citizens in government changes depending on whether the country has a federal, confederation, or unitary system. In a federal system, like the U.S., power is divided between national and state governments, giving citizens multiple ways to participate. People can vote in national elections for leaders like the president and Congress, state elections for governors and legislators, and local elections for mayors and city councils. They can also influence policy through referenda or ballot initiatives. A confederation is different because the central government has very limited power, and most decisions are made at the state or regional level. This means citizens mainly engage with their state governments instead of a strong national authority. Historical examples include the Articles of Confederation in early U.S. history and the European Union today, where people vote for their national leaders and for representatives in the European Parliament. In a unitary system, like France or the U.K., the national government holds most of the power, while local governments carry out its policies without much independence. Citizens mainly interact with the central government through voting in national elections, since local governments follow the central authority’s decisions.

The division of power refers to how authority is shared among different levels of government. In a federal system, power is divided between national and state governments, each with its own responsibilities. For example, the national government handles defense and foreign policy, while states manage education and local laws. Some responsibilities, like taxation and law enforcement, are shared. In a confederation, the states hold most of the power, and the national government relies on them for things like trade agreements or military cooperation. Under the Articles of Confederation, the U.S. national government couldn’t collect taxes or enforce laws, making it weak. In a unitary system, the central government has all the power and can delegate responsibilities to local governments, but it can also take that power back whenever it wants. This system focuses on national unity and efficiency rather than dividing authority among different levels.

The federal government played a major role in shaping New York State’s response to the Covid-19 pandemic, mostly through financial aid and policy guidance, The CARES Act and the American Rescue Plan provided funding for stimulus checks, unemployment benefits, and support for state and local governments. FEMA covered costs for emergency supplies and temporary hospitals, allowing New York to improve healthcare, expand testing, and roll out vaccinations. The federal government also issued public health guidelines, which New York followed by enforcing mask mandates, business closures, and social distancing rules. However, New York sometimes went beyond federal recommendations, like implementing stricter lockdowns and vaccine requirements. The state worked with federal agencies to set up large vaccination sites, such as the one at the Javits Center. The National Guard helped distribute food, medical supplies, and manage testing and vaccination sites. Additionally, the federal government encouraged states to coordinate their policies, leading New York to team up with New Jersey and Connecticut to create regional travel and quarantine restrictions for high-risk states. This cooperation helped prevent confusion and made pandemic policies more consistent across state lines.

Discussion 7.1

The involvement of citizens in government can change a lot based on whether a country uses a federal, confederation, or unitary system. This is mainly because of how power is divided among different levels of government. In a federal system, like in the United States, Canada, or Germany, power is shared between a national government and regional governments, such as states or provinces. Citizens have the chance to participate in government at various levels. They can vote in national elections for leaders like the president or members of Congress, as well as in state elections for governors and state lawmakers. Additionally, they can take part in local elections for mayors and city councils. Sometimes, citizens even get to vote directly on specific policies through referenda. This system allows people to push for different policies at different levels of government. On the other hand, a confederation is a loose group of independent states that give limited power to a weaker central authority. Examples from history include the Articles of Confederation in the early United States and the European Union. In a confederation, citizens mainly interact with their state or regional governments since the central government has very little power. The national government doesn’t directly control individuals; it operates through the states. This means that citizens might have different rights and responsibilities based on their state’s laws, as there isn’t always a consistent policy across the board. In modern confederations like the European Union, citizens can vote for their national governments and also for representatives in a limited central government, like the European Parliament. In a unitary system, the central government has most or all of the governing power, while local governments mainly serve as administrative branches. This means that local governments don’t have much independence and follow the rules set by the central authority.

The division of power is about how authority is shared among different levels of government. This idea is really important for how a country is run because it helps make sure that no one group has all the power. In a federal system, for example, power is split between the national government and state governments, each having their own specific jobs. The national government handles things like defense and foreign affairs, while states take care of education and local laws. They also share some responsibilities, like taxation and law enforcement. In the U.S., states manage their own education systems, but the federal government supports them with funding and guidelines. On the other hand, in a confederation, the states keep most of the power, and the central government has very little authority, often relying on the states to work together on issues like trade. An example of this is the Articles of Confederation, where the federal government couldn’t collect taxes or enforce laws. In a unitary system, the central government has all the power and can give some authority to local governments, but it can take it back whenever it wants. For instance, in France, the national government controls major areas like education and healthcare, while local governments handle smaller tasks. The main goal of dividing power in federal and confederation systems is to stop any one group from becoming too powerful, while unitary systems focus more on keeping the country united and running smoothly.

During the COVID-19 pandemic, the U.S. federal government significantly influenced New York State’s response, primarily through financial support. Relief packages like the CARES Act and the American Rescue Plan provided funds for stimulus checks, unemployment benefits, and aid to state and local governments. FEMA also helped cover costs for emergency supplies and temporary hospitals, enabling New York to support healthcare, distribute vaccines, and assist unemployed residents.The federal government set health guidelines that New York initially followed closely, enforcing strict mask and business restrictions. However, New York leaders, including Governor Andrew Cuomo, sometimes implemented even stricter measures, such as early business shutdowns and vaccination mandates for certain workers. The state collaborated with federal agencies to establish large vaccination sites. Additionally, the National Guard was deployed to assist in distributing food and medical supplies and managing testing and vaccination sites, including the Javits Center. This federal support was crucial for New York in navigating the pandemic’s challenges.The federal government played a big role in how New York handled travel and quarantine rules between states. In the summer of 2020, New York teamed up with New Jersey and Connecticut to set up quarantine rules for people coming from states that had a high risk of spreading the virus, following the advice from the federal government. The federal leaders wanted the states to cooperate and create consistent rules instead of having different policies all over the place.

Discussion Board 7.1

  1. Describe the primary differences in the role of citizens in government, among the federal, confederation, and unitary systems.
  2. Briefly explain how you understand the system of division of power.
  3. How does the federal government shape the actions of state and local governments? Write your answer based on doing a bit of research on how the federal government has influenced the actions of NY state and local governments, during the COVID-19 pandemic.