The reading excerpts from “Beyond the Gender Binary” by Alok Vaid Manon touches base on gender by going into depth about conformity, fluidity, and experiences Alok has been through as an individual who identifies as nonbinary in society. Throughout reading the excerpts I learned more about the experiences one goes through when living in society as someone who identifies as nonbinary. However, I also learned more about gender as a whole and how the continuous evolution of the topic gender hasn’t quite fully been accepted in society, nor has society grasped the whole subject of gender and the ideas within that subject. We can think of gender as the root of a tree and the more we learn about different ways others associate with gender, the tree will continue to grow with different branches. Therefore, when we create more space for others when it comes to identifying with gender, the concept of gender as a whole will continue to grow and evolve. An important topic I learned from the text is the idea that the gender system as a whole is not only outdated but has been the cause of a lot of problems in society today. Alok tries to open us up to the ideology that the whole gender system has constantly found ways to exclude individuals who don’t label or identify themselves simply as just a male or a female. Alok goes into detail about the gender binary and how it is set up for people to fail; this also includes individuals like me and you. You may be thinking, what is the gender binary? The gender binary is a system of gender classification in which all people are categorized as being either male or female. Alok describes the gender binary system as being more concerned with gender norms than it is with updating and educating the system on the different categories of gender individuals associate themselves with that isn’t just a male or a female. Alok states, “we are led to believe that there are only two genders, ‘man’ and ‘woman’, and these genders are narrow, separate, and opposite. We are taught from a very young age that this is how things have always been and this is the only way to live.” This statement resonated with me because growing up my parents were separated and I lived with my mom but I visited my dad every weekend and during the summertime. Even though I identify myself as a woman I have always liked dressing like a tomboy as well as playing video games and playing sports. My mom was always against me enjoying and dressing as what was called “boyish” things. I was always taught from my mom that boys can only like boy things such as sports, wrestling, and the color blue; and girls like me can only like girl things such as the color pink, barbie dolls, playing dress-up, and make-up. My mom, without realizing it, made me feel ashamed for enjoying things that I was taught were only specifically meant for boys. Gender was distinctly separated in my household and she made sure that I understood that anything other than associating as a girl or being interested in “girly” things was never to be tolerated or talked about nor would it ever be accepted in her home. I feel as though as society continues to evolve; moving forward we should take the initiative to change the gender binary system so it is more inclusive to all who don’t associate themselves in the most simplest way as a male or female but make it inclusive to those who associate themselves in other ways we may not even know of yet. It is important to include everyone in the conversation of gender so it is fair and comprehensive. Another important topic I learned throughout the excerpts by Alok is the fact that power and control both contribute to the broken gender binary system and overall the world as a whole. With control people can gain power and with power people can continuously control the narrative and conversation of gender without letting outsiders give their input and suggestions. Alok states, “Arguments against gender non-conforming people are about maintaining power and control.” This is a powerful statement because it helps us to understand that when we allow society to continuously control the conversation about gender, then we are allowing the binary norm system to maintain the power and control they have over the ideology of gender and what terms we use to associate gender with. If we want the binary norm to evolve and become more inclusive and considerate to all individuals in the world, then we need to regain the power and control back to steer the direction of our own narratives; making sure everyone’s voice is heard and everyone is seen and accepted once and for all. Lastly, a third important topic I learned throughout Alok’s excerpts is another strategy that people use to make the gender binary system seem like a given instead of a decision; dismissal. Alok states, “In order to even get a seat at the table, people have to believe that you exist.” Another powerful and impactful statement made by Alok because it acknowledges the fact that people still refuse to acknowledge that gender non-conforming people exist.
Author Archives: Sydney Maldonado
Sydney Maldonado – Discussion #3
I believe that to move beyond the gender binary for Alok, we must first acknowledge that there is more than one option when identifying ourselves within gender. Instead of just viewing gender as manhood or womanhood we should expand our view on gender and acknowledge that gender is so much more tremendous and interesting than that. Rather than just accepting gender can only be a man or a woman; we must first accept that gender can be an infinity of options beyond woman or man. We must also regain control and power back that has been taken from us for so long by society’s norms and the outdated ideology of the gender binary system. If gender non-conforming individuals took control of the conversation and the narrative when it comes to gender then more voices would be heard and the future generations to come will have more options to identify and connect themselves with. In the end, the world would be more inclusive, understanding, and accepting. Even though I identify myself as a cisgender female my identity in a way goes against binary norms because I am not fully interested or invested in the things a woman would or should be within societys norms and the binary norm. I’m a female who views herself more as a tomboy who enjoys things that are labeled only for men like playing “manly” sports like football and dressing in “boyish” things that aren’t skirts, dresses, or high heels. I’m also a bi-sexual female and even though that focuses on my sexual orientation, as a female I feel as though that doesn’t fit the binary norm when identifying as a woman. Throughout some of our households, throughout school, and just every-day life it is drilled in our heads that man and woman were meant for each other; they were meant to reproduce and create more generations for the future years. However, we aren’t taught nor is it drilled in our heads that we can identify as so much more than that and we can freely express ourselves without worrying if it goes along with our identities. Instead these identities were put into a box and labeled the binary norm without any thought or room for change and expansion. My gender identity however, in some aspects fit into the binary norm just because I identify as a woman who is cisgender. That alone fits the binary norm neatly and is accepted effortlessly within society without question or judgment.
Sydney Maldonado – Discussion #2
In the essay, “Feminist Politics Where We Stand” by Bell Hooks defines feminism as: “a movement to end sexism, sexist exploitation, and oppression.” I understand this definition to mean that although feminism is a movement to fight for the equality of women throughout society it also means so much more then that. Feminism is the development to end prejudice, stereotyping, and discrimination against both men and women as a whole to fight for equality within the world. Before reading this essay, my definition of feminism was a movement that fought for the equality of women in a male dominated world. As we know gender roles plays a big part in our society today as it always has throughout history, therefore, my idea of feminism was the fight for women to be seen as more then just women but as strong, independent leaders that can also guide the world in a positive direction just as much as men if not more. Hooks definition of feminism does not quite compare to mine as she digs more deeper into the root of the problem when it comes to feminism and the true idea of hat the movement is all about. Hooks states, “Masses of people think that feminism is always and only about women seeking to be equal to men. And a huge majority of these folks think feminism is anti-male. Their misunderstanding of feminist politics relfects the reality that most folks learn about feminism from patriarchal mass media.” Hooks investigates further that most people, like myself, have only one idea of feminism and what that looks like in the real world, however, it is so much more then that. Feminism is a movement to end sexsim and the oppression sexism has created in society which has made it almost impossible for both men and women to live harmoniously and equally together. Before reading “Sex and Gender 101” by Kyl Myers my take on gender overall had already involved the further complexities of biological sex, gender, gender roles, and sexual orientation. I already understood the concept that just because someone is biologically born as a male does not mean that they will identify as a male later on in their life. I also understood the concept that sexuality is fluid and can continuously change the more a person evolves throughout their life. However, the article did not only refresh my memory but helped me even further understand the concepts of sex and gender separatley and together.
Reading Reflection #1
As the world continues to evolve and society continues to change with it; the topics of sex, gender, and feminisim has continued to progress and expand our way of thinking about these topics and how we view them. Through two specific texts by two different authors; I want to further explain in depth what the readings mean, what they are trying to convey, and the important points we should all take away from both texts. In the article “Sex & Gender 101” written by Kyl Myers focuses on the basics when it comes to the topics of sex and gender. Myers focuses on the foundational terms which make up some form of who we are. Myers touches base on the foundational terms such as; biological sex, gender, and sexual orientation. One important concept Myers explains in the article is the idea that a person’s biological sex, gender, identity, gender expression, and sexual orientation are not mutually exclusive. The statement within itself is powerful and further explains how just because a male or a female may identify as cisgender does not automatically mean that individual is a heterosexual. When we put terms like gender and sexual orientation together amongst other foundational terms based around sex and gender, then we constantly put people in the same groups without truly getting to know who they are and what they view themselves as. For example, myself, I am a female who identifies as cisgender however, my sexual orientation is bi-sexual. Throughout high school, people in my school constantly assumed because I was a cisgender female I only liked boys and when I did express to them my sexual orientation they laughed it off, didn’t believe me, and made statements like “you’re too pretty to like girls.” This type of experience, labeling, and stereotyping essentially made me not want to express myself anymore to anyone ever again. Therefore, the information that Myers is describing throughout this article makes room for readers to further educate themselves and start a conversation about sex and gender overall that has never been had before or is not spoken about enough. Another important concept from the text is the fact that in countries like America, young boys and girls are taught their gender roles and how distinctive they are from each other. Boys are taught at a young age to be rough, aggressive, rugged, to be the “man” and the “boss” as they grow up. Girls are taught at a young age the ways of being a housewife; learning how to cook, clean, be quiet, submissive, and overall weak. As society continues to evolve and the definition of foundational terms like gender and sex are expanding into different meanings it is vital to change the way children are being brought up in the world. Myers is pointing out that with educating yourself more on the depth of sexual orientation and gender you can make a change by becoming aware of the stereotypical problems and stigmas when it comes to sex and gender. Lastly, another important message from the text is the idea that if we don’t change the way we view sex and gender then we will constantly have set gender roles and sterotypes for both men and women. If we continuously put men in a box and women in a box without having room for more different types of gender identities then we will never have a positive shift in the construction of gender, sex, and its overall culture in society.
In the article, “Feminist Politics: Where we stand” by bell hooks focuses on the topic of feminism and the sterotypical concepts behind it. Hooks goes into detail about her goal to end sexist oppression and continue to educate others on the true definition of feminism by describing it as a movement that is not all about being anti-male, but focuses on the equality of both male and females. An important concept Hooks speaks on is the message that all sexist thinking and actions are the problem whether it is by a male, female, child, or adult. By understanding the idea of sexism overall so we can truly understand the idea of feminism. This is an important message to not only understand but educate to others in our lives because it can help spread awareness to feminism and make a change in the world for not only women but men as well. If we end sexism in our society then we would make a way for feminism to grow and truly impact the world in a positive way. Another important concept Hooks mentions is just how important feminism is to our society. Feminism won’t end all our world problems and create a perfect world full of peace and equality howvever, it can and will still impact the world in a way where men and women can co-exist without stereotypes; while creating a welcoming and beloved community. Hooks mentions the intention that feminism can touch and change our lives if we can truly grasp what feminism and the movement of feminsim is. Lastly, Hooks brings up the message that without clear definitions on feminism we won’t be able to move forward with the feminism movement throughout society. It is key for us to not only get the definition of feminism right but to instill this definition in others so they can continue to share the message and keep the movement alive until there is solid change in society.
Sydney Maldonado – Discussion #1
My name is Sydney Maldonado and I am a communications major at BMCC. I decided to become a communications major because BMCC doesn’t have a specific major for broadcasting journalism. However, I am very appreciative and thankful I did major in communications because I have learned so much through different COM classes; I have also had the opportunity to take other classes like gender women study classes and theater. Having the opportunity to learn from these different types of classes has helped me improve my writing, thinking, and understanding overall for different topics. I enjoy doing make-up, painting, reading, and writing. I dislike the winter, so you can imagine the type of time I’m having at the moment with the cold weather and mountains. of snow everywhere throughout the city. I also dislike clutter; I’m kind of an OCD type of person therefore, I am very organized when it comes to work, school, and my home. The idea of things being messy and unorganized in any area of my life really bothers me. I was born and raised in Brooklyn, New York my whole life, however I am Puerto Rican and Colombian. I value my family above anything else; I’m very close to my family and am a strong believer that family is everything. I have three sisters that I am very close to and rely on them for just about everything. I also value my aspirations, as I hold them to a high standard and try to push myself as hard as I can to achieve my dreams and accomplish my vision that I have for my life. My hopes and dreams are to not only have a career in the broadcasting journalism world but to also become an entrepreneur and have my own business as a make-up artist. I’ve always been interested in the world; the important things that go on and important stories that deserve and need to be told. I want to make a difference, meaning I want to be a voice for those who are not heard enough or not heard at all. I use the pronouns she/her/hers. I am taking this course because I’ve taken a gender studies class before and truly enjoyed it; I know this class will help me learn more about women and their history. Especially being a woman, I love to learn more about others, their stories, and what they have accomplished in the world or the ways in which they have changed the world.