Dylan Dong Discussion 4

I would say some of my main privileges lie in class. I am able to attend college. I’ve never had to worry about what or IF we would eat the next day. I live in a city where I have easy access to water and fresh food. My family (mother and sister) are supportive of me and my queer identity, which is one of the privileges I am most thankful for. I get very emotional and even feel “survivors guilt”, when I think about all of the LGBT people out there being physically, verbally, mentally abused by their parents/the world for their existence, and those still suffering in conversion camps. I am very lucky that there is something about me that prevents people from queer-bashing me on the street, or general street harassment. Every single LGBT person I know has experienced queerphobic harassment on the street, at least once, and many still deal with it on a regular basis, and it breaks my heart. Another privilege I hold is being able to be seen as a male in certain contexts, when I want or need to, for safety. 

My oppression comes from being parts of multiple communities: Asian-American, Latinx, Queer, Trans, Gender-non conforming, disabled, 2nd gen, etc. I go about my existence very aware of how I move, and how I look. I have to code switch in certain situations to make myself more “palatable” and likely to be accepted. Like dress more like a cis-male when I worked in an office. Being disabled, in New York City is a huge frustration as barely any of the train stations are accessible, making it a struggle for me to go places, as I also don’t drive.

The “What is Privilege” video is great because I think the visual aid makes it more impactful. I’ve experienced this exercise before and it leads to further conversation on difficult topics and is beneficial to everyone who participates. it is a very good idea to incorporate this kind of exercise in school. When you can physically, visually see how “far ahead” you are to someone in the line, it’s easier to quantify and understand the degree of your privilege. The exercise in the video touches on sexual orientation, jobs, poverty, health, religious holidays, supportive family etc. Even the people who participated in the video were very visibly emotionally moved. The Asian man said “It’s interesting being an Asian-American, you’re not really sure where you fall on the spectrum of privilege.” I relate to this as I notice that America is very White vs. Black focused racially. Even the “White Privilege: Unpacking the Invisible Knapsack.” article, phrases it this way as the author prefaces her list as the things she is able to do with ease, that the African American people in her life cannot. The list can be informative and provoke self-reflection for other POC, and not just white people. We have varying levels of privilege, and many that are race specific.

No matter what kind of racial group or community you are part of you experience some degree of privilege. And that no oppression in one form negates whatever your overall privilege you may possess. I know someone who believed that because he is deaf it negates his white privilege. And the article “Unpacking the “White Privilege: Unpacking the Invisible Knapsack.” was a resource I was able to show him to help expand and challenge his mindset, without having to use my knowledge as a person of color, to place the emotional burden on myself to explain big things like types of privilege.

To say someone has privilege, means that they are in a position of power. They are able to do certain things without giving it a second thought, like questioning their safety, and without experiencing discrimination for being a part of that group.

Someone being oppressed is being stripped of power. They are harmed or limited by others because of the community/racial group they belong to. There is a hierarchical structure to society and oppression would “set you back” like physically represented in the “What Is Privilege” video by people stepping backwards in the line. Oppression strips us of power. 

7 thoughts on “Dylan Dong Discussion 4

  1. Arianda Fernandez

    Hi Dylan,
    Your response was so well thought out and specific where it needed to be. I really like how you highlighted that there are varying levels of privilege and that many are actually race specific. Thank you for sharing about the person you know that assumes that because he is deaf, it negates his white privilege and were able to use this resource to help broaden his point of view. I also, really liked your definitions of privilege and oppression where one is about power and the other about being stripped of it.

  2. Brianne Waychoff

    Great post. Yes, being disabled in this city is difficult – navigating the MTA is nearly impossible and access-a-ride is unreliable at best. Thank you for noting this – it is so often taken for granted. I also wanted to agree that in the US the focus is usually on black/white. This is beginning to change in some things I read, but our history is deeply entrenched. That article about the knapsack was written in the late 80s, so it can be a bit outdated in its language and consideration.

  3. Yin Lin

    Hi Dylan,
    As a person grew up in China and moved to the states a few year ago, when I started to access informations related to people of color, I always feel like being in the middle. There are stereotypes about asians and some opinions don’t consider asians are the people of color or even put asians with white people category that makes me confused.
    The good thing is people start to have more awareness about them and things are getting changing. It is not the ideal world yet but it is changing.

    1. Dylan Dong Post author

      It is very confusing and very frustrating! It is pretty common that Asians here (usually east Asians) aren’t seen as POC enough. And then get seen as more white-adjacent, like you mention. We aren’t represented in media and pop culture which definitely adds to the reasons Asians are overlooked and ignored. I think the an “Asian privilege” in terms of being a person of color, is that we do not get targeted by law enforcement to the same amount that black and latinx people do.

      Also, I just want to say I hope you are able to stay safe during this time with the increase in attacks.

  4. Mamadou A Diallo

    Hey Dylan, I enjoyed reading your discussion about this week’s topics, I like how you stated that No matter what racial group or community you are part of a degree of privilege is still there for everybody, it’s not equal but it’s kind of unique. I also think the more people feed into white privilege; they forget about all the other privileges other people have… that don’t even have to do with being white. There are good Privileges for all kinds of people old people, The disable, black, Asian, Hispanic, poor and the rich.

Leave a Reply