The most surprising part of this week’s readings and the film had to be the stigma surrounding menstruation in India. In Period: End Of Sentence, the part that floored me was that some, if not most of these women, had to drop out of their education journey because of the challenges and complications of menstruating without having the proper supplies. It is not right that having access to affordable menstrual products is considered a luxury. In my opinion, these products should be supplied at no cost, and there should also be nothing taboo about a woman’s period. There is a part of the documentary where they mention that women who are menstruating can’t enter the temples because they are believed to be dirty. They don’t even pray to any gods. In 12 Reasons It Should Be Illegal For Doctors Not To Treat Trans People by Diana Tourjée, what shocked me and will always shock me is how anyone can believe that a human being doesn’t deserve medical care. Regardless of how a person identifies, it is still a human right, or at least it should be. In A Birth Story, written by Dr. Dana-Ain Davis, what surprised me the most was that Leconté had to walk anywhere just a few hours after giving birth. Not just walking but pushing her newborn and her IV down the hall, and no wheelchair was offered while her husband carried all their belongings.
The connection between all three readings/film is how these people have experienced discrimination when it comes to healthcare. In the film a woman states, “The thing is when there is patriarchy, it takes time to talk about something related to women.” Menstruation is natural, and women shouldn’t be treated poorly because of it; men can’t just decide periods are a problem. In the reading by Diana Tourjée, Simon Chartrand writes, “I am a transgender person with a disability, and the proposed rule will compromise my unalienable rights. … I need constant access to healthcare, and I have experienced discrimination many times in the past”. I can’t wrap my head around the hatred people project toward others. If a person requires medical attention, there shouldn’t be a reason to deprive them of it, especially if they are disabled and need it more often. In the reading by Dr. Dana-Ain Davis, she writes, “Annoyed that he had to come down to the labor and delivery unit, he commented to one of the doctors, in front of LeConté and everyone in the room, “Why don’t you just give her a C-section? I am not coming down here again.” LeConté felt invisible and disrespected” about the anesthesiologist who administered too much epidural, causing her to feel dizzy. If the patient were not a black woman, she would not have been treated the way LeConté was.
The format in which the stories are shared impacts my understanding of medical oppression. The stories felt very personal, and I felt as though I’ve gotten to know these people and how they’ve been medically oppressed. The film showed me how different these women live and their struggles with something that naturally happens, such as menstruation. The clips where they were very obviously uncomfortable talking about it helped me grasp just how taboo the topic is to them. At one point during the film, it is mentioned that it isn’t a conversation between mother and daughter nor husband and wife.
Hi Lizbeth,
I would definitely, based on how each story takes place it gives us this really raw and in-depth connotation no matter how different or similar the circumstances where. So for me that was another thing that stood out, being that we are only just mere readers yet the impact that these stories are capable of having on us is a large amount. Oppression within the medical field is one type of oppression I feel as though no one should have to bare, due to what they might look like alongside many other factors that may make up who these individuals are.
Lizbeth,
Reading your post made me feel exactly how I felt reading and watching the materials of this week- shock and disbelief. The film was incredibly eye-opening to the privileges we have in the Unites States and having the visual of the lack of knowledge and education was mind blowing. Yes, that fact you brought up from the film about wives not talking to the husbands or daughters about menstruation really got me too. I’m constantly baffled with how cultures and societies follow norms like “no communication” especially when something is embarrassing. That in itself is oppressing! How else is a brand new human beings that is born suppose to navigate this world without guidance. Norms set in place so as to not disturb patriarchy.
Hi Lizbeth,
Thanks for your sharing and all the readings and film let us have a chance to know how the oppression level is for women and LGBTQ people. It is eye opened and it is important for people to stand out and sent their voices out so that we can see the pain, then we can seek the solutions.
I didnt really think about the fact that the documentary and passages have a connections. When I do think about it they all show me different aspects of heatlh discrimination. I think discrimation / shaming can start within your own people or culture like in the documentary. It can also be racial like shown in the reading by Diana Tourjée . Besides the color of skin It can be from the choices that make .. to be who they really want to be like in the vice reading.
Hey, yes I agree that it’s unbelievable how a person can deny another human being medical treatment simply because of what they identify with. People like that shouldn’t even be in the medical field as the whole point is to treat the person regardless of status or gender.